01
Best overall pick
Fallsburg Pizza the Frazeysburg Connection
Central Frazeysburg • Small-Town Carryout And Dine-In Pizzeria • Local Favorite
A cozy village standby turning out hefty, well-topped pies and friendly service.
Fallsburg Pizza feels like the classic hometown shop, with straightforward crusts, plenty of cheese, and toppings piled on without fuss. The menu leans into crowd-pleasers—pepperoni, deluxe combos, and loaded specialty pies that travel well for pickup. It’s the kind of place where the staff learns your usual order if you stop in often enough.
02
Best for hearty takeout
Scrappy's Pizza
East Frazeysburg • Casual Hometown Pizza And Sub Shop • Best For Big Appetites
Thick, filling pizzas and classic subs make this an easy weeknight takeout choice.
Scrappy’s leans into comfort food—think substantial crusts, generous cheese, and plenty of meat on the popular specialty pies. Alongside pizza, you’ll find oven-baked subs and other familiar shop staples that round out a family order. It’s a go-to when you want a straightforward, satisfying meal without leaving the village.
03
Best for families
Village Pizzeria & Kitchen
West Frazeysburg • Family-Friendly Village Restaurant With Pizza • Sit-Down Crowd-Pleaser
A small, relaxed spot where pizza anchors a broader comfort-food menu.
Village Pizzeria & Kitchen offers a simple, family-oriented dining room where pizza shares the spotlight with other homestyle dishes. Pies come in familiar builds—cheese, pepperoni, and veggie—aimed squarely at mixed groups with kids in tow. If you want a casual sit-down meal without driving to Newark or Zanesville, this is the logical choice.
04
Classic Italian road-trip stop
Adornetto's Selected Italian
Zanesville • Classic Italian Restaurant Known For Pizza • Worth-The-Drive Classic
A long-running Zanesville institution where thin, saucy pies share the menu with red-sauce Italian staples.
About a 20–25 minute drive from Frazeysburg, Adornetto’s is the kind of old-school Italian place people build traditions around. The pizza leans toward a classic Ohio style: thinner crust, a bright tomato sauce, and plenty of cheese, with simple toppings done well. If you’re making an evening of it, this is the spot for a sit-down meal that feels like a local ritual rather than a quick bite.
05
Best group-friendly option
Pizza Cottage
Newark Along Oh-16 • Lively Regional Pizza Chain Restaurant • Best For Groups And Game Nights
A bigger, busier option with wide topping choices and plenty of space to spread out.
Newark’s Pizza Cottage is a popular stop for Frazeysburg residents who don’t mind a short drive in exchange for more seating and a broader menu. Pizzas range from straightforward one-topping pies to loaded specialty combinations, with salads and appetizers that make it easy to feed a crowd. It’s a smart pick when you’ve got a larger group, want to linger over dinner, or are meeting friends from around the region.