01
Best hometown staple
Lem's Pizza
Village Center, Fredericksburg • Small-Town Takeout Shop • Go-To Hometown Slice
Classic, generously topped pies that feel like the village living room on a busy night.
Lem's is the kind of place where they know your order by heart if you live anywhere near Fredericksburg. The crust is sturdy enough to carry plenty of cheese and toppings, and the menu sticks to the crowd-pleasing basics. Call ahead on weekend evenings; the parking lot fills fast when ball teams and families roll in at the same time.
02
Old-school Wooster classic
Coccia House
Downtown Wooster • Old-School Italian-American Pizzeria • Legendary Local Institution
Thick, saucy, cheese-heavy pies served in a no-frills dining room that has barely changed in decades.
Coccia House is one of those places people in Wayne County argue about in the best way: everyone has a favorite topping combo and a story to go with it. The square-cut pizzas come piled high, with a slightly sweet sauce and a crust that stays tender under all that cheese. Expect a wait at peak times, but the old-school atmosphere and big portions make it feel like a small trip back in time.
03
Worth-the-drive pick
Park Street Pizza
Downtown Sugarcreek • Wood-Fired Farm-To-Table Spot • Destination For Pizza Road-Trippers
Creative, wood-fired pies built on local ingredients in a lively small-town setting.
Park Street Pizza draws people from all over Amish country with its focus on fresh, locally sourced toppings and crisp, charred crusts. Classic pepperoni sits alongside seasonal creations, so you can keep it simple or try something new each visit. It is a bit of a drive from Fredericksburg, but many locals consider it the special-occasion pizza place for the area.
04
Best for feeding a crowd
East of Chicago Pizza
South Millersburg • Family Pizza Chain With Buffet • Best For Big Family Orders
Reliable pan and thin-crust pizzas with plenty of topping choices and family-friendly deals.
The Millersburg East of Chicago is a practical choice when you are hauling home pizza for a houseful of relatives or a youth group. The menu runs from thick, edge-to-edge pan pies to foldable thin crust, plus wings, breadsticks, and dessert pizzas that make it easy to please mixed tastes. It is less about ambiance and more about getting a stack of hot boxes in the car without breaking the budget.
05
Best cozy sit-down option
Broken Rocks Cafe & Bakery
Market Street, Downtown Wooster • Casual Bistro With Artisan Pizzas • Best For Date Night
Handcrafted, restaurant-style pizzas with thoughtful toppings in a warm, brick-lined dining room.
Broken Rocks is not a traditional pizzeria, but its pizzas are a standout part of the menu and a nice step up from takeout boxes. Expect thinner, flavorful crusts, well-balanced toppings, and options that pair nicely with a glass of wine or a local beer. It is an easy recommendation when you want pizza but also a relaxed sit-down meal in downtown Wooster.