01
Classic sit-down favorite
Adornetto's Selected Italian Dining
Maple Avenue, Zanesville • Classic Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria • Best For Family Dinners
A long-running Zanesville institution known for its saucy, cheese-heavy pies and old-school Italian dining room.
If you ask around Fultonham for a “real” pizza place, Adornetto's Selected Italian Dining is one of the first names you’ll hear. The dining room feels like a time capsule in the best way, with generous portions, red sauce comfort food, and pizzas built on a soft, flavorful crust. It’s the spot to linger over a carafe of soda or wine while big shareable pies hit the table one after another.
02
Takeout staple
Adornetto's North
North Zanesville • Carry-Out Pizza Shop • Go-To For Takeout
The carry-out arm of the Adornetto’s empire, turning out the same signature pies in a quick, no-fuss format.
Adornetto's North is ideal when you want that familiar Zanesville-style pie without committing to a full sit-down meal. The menu leans heavily on the classics—pepperoni, sausage, and loaded combo pizzas with plenty of cheese and a slightly sweet red sauce. Call ahead from Fultonham, swing through the pickup window, and you can be back home with hot pizza in under an hour round-trip.
03
Crowd-pleasing chain
Pizza Cottage
North Zanesville Shopping Corridor • Casual Family Pizzeria • Best For Groups And Kids
An Ohio-born mini-chain with a roomy dining area, plenty of toppings, and consistently crowd-pleasing pies.
Pizza Cottage in Zanesville is a reliable pick when you’ve got a mix of tastes in the group and don’t want any complaints. The crust runs in the middle ground—not too thin, not too thick—with edge-to-edge toppings and options ranging from build-your-own to specialty pies loaded with meats or veggies. With TVs, roomy booths, and a casual vibe, it’s an easy spot for birthday parties, team celebrations, or a relaxed dinner after a day exploring the countryside around Fultonham.
04
Craft beer & pizza combo
Weasel Boy Brewing Company
Downtown Zanesville Riverfront • Brewpub With Artisan Pizza • Best For Craft Beer Lovers
A small brewery on the river that pairs house beers with creative, stone-baked pizzas in a relaxed, artsy space.
For something a little different from the standard pie-and-soda routine, Weasel Boy Brewing Company delivers. Their pizzas lean artisanal, with thinner crusts, thoughtfully chosen toppings, and combinations that go beyond the typical pepperoni-and-mushroom lineup. It’s a great choice for date night or meeting friends, with live music some evenings and a laid-back taproom feel that makes the short drive from Fultonham worth it.
05
Quick thin-crust fix
Donatos Pizza
East Zanesville • Fast-Casual Chain Pizzeria • Best For Fast, Consistent Pizza
A regional chain known for its ultra-thin crust and edge-to-edge toppings, ideal when you need pizza in a hurry.
Donatos in Zanesville is all about crisp, cracker-thin crusts and neatly layered toppings that reach every corner of the box. It’s a smart option if you’re coming into town for errands and want to grab something quick to take back to Fultonham. Order ahead online or by phone, and you can be in and out with a hot pie and a salad or wings in just a few minutes.