01
Best overall pick
Burrata Woodfired
Downtown Mount Vernon • Wood-Fired Pizzeria With Craft Toppings • Destination For Pizza Night
Modern and cozy, Burrata Woodfired turns out blistered, wood-fired pies that feel a step above your standard college-town pizza stop.
This downtown spot is where many locals steer visitors when they ask where to get the “good pizza” near Gambier. The menu leans on a chewy, wood-fired crust with thoughtful toppings, from classic margherita to more adventurous seasonal combinations. It’s a great pick when you have time to sit down over a couple of pies and a salad instead of grabbing a quick box to go.
02
Classic local favorite
Ron's Pizza
Coshocton Avenue Corridor, Mount Vernon • Old-School Hometown Pizzeria • Local Favorite For Carryout
Ron's Pizza is a longstanding Mount Vernon staple known for its slightly sweet sauce, sturdy crust, and generous cheese.
If you ask someone who grew up in the area where they ordered pizza as a kid, Ron’s is likely to come up first. The pies are straightforward and satisfying, with a classic Ohio-style crust that holds up well for carryout back to campus. It’s the kind of spot that excels at big, shareable orders for study groups and game days.
03
Best low-key slice stop
Dirko's Pizza
East Side Of Mount Vernon • Casual Neighborhood Pizza Shop • Best For Quick, No-Frills Pies
Dirko's Pizza is a laid-back counter-service joint turning out well-priced pies and subs with a loyal local following.
Dirko’s focuses on the basics: solid crust, plenty of toppings, and fast service. It’s especially handy when you want something filling and affordable without a long wait or a formal sit-down meal. Call ahead for pickup on your way back to Gambier and you can be eating hot slices in the dorm within minutes of leaving town.
04
Best for groups and families
Pizza Cottage
Coshocton Road, Mount Vernon • Family-Friendly Pizza And Pasta Spot • Great For Teams And Big Tables
Pizza Cottage offers roomy dine-in space, thickly topped pies, and shareable appetizers that work well for families and teams.
With plenty of seating and a broad menu, Pizza Cottage is an easy choice when you’re feeding a mixed group of kids, visiting parents, or teammates. Pizzas tend to be hearty and topping-heavy, and there are wings, salads, and desserts for people who want more than just a slice. It’s an especially convenient stop after games or events off campus when everyone wants to sit down and linger over dinner.
05
Most convenient late-night option
Creno's Pizza
North Mount Vernon • Classic Delivery-Focused Pizzeria • Go-To For Late-Night Delivery
Creno's Pizza is a reliable choice for classic, cheesy pies delivered to nearby dorms and rentals when it’s too late to cook.
Creno’s leans into comfort food, with thick layers of cheese, crowd-pleasing toppings, and plenty of sides like garlic bread and wings. It’s not fancy, but that’s part of the appeal when you’re ordering at the end of a long day and just want hot, reliable pizza to show up at the door. Students and locals alike keep it in their regular delivery rotation for easy weeknights and late-night cravings.