01
Best overall pick
Cal's Pizza & Chicken
Downtown Garrettsville • Classic Small-Town Pizza And Chicken Shop • Neighborhood Staple
A hometown go-to for generously topped pies and shareable chicken dinners.
Tucked close to the heart of Garrettsville, Cal's feels like the place everyone in town has on speed dial. The pizza leans classic Midwest: sturdy crust, plenty of cheese, and straightforward toppings that land well with just about any crowd. It’s the kind of spot you call when you want reliable, no-fuss comfort food for a game night or last-minute family dinner.
02
Best for fast delivery
Domino's Pizza
State Street Corridor • National Delivery And Carryout Chain • Best For Late-Night Orders
Fast, predictable pizza with all the modern ordering tools when convenience matters most.
Garrettsville’s Domino's on State Street is the workhorse option when you care more about timing and tracking than ambiance. The menu covers the chain’s full range, from build-your-own pies to specialty pizzas, wings, and sides, all easy to customize through the app. It’s especially handy for late homework nights, team dinners, or when you’re rolling back into town and want a hot pizza waiting on the way home.
03
Best for families
Pizza Hut
State Street Commercial Strip • Sit-Down Chain With Pizza, Wings, And Pasta • Family-Friendly Choice
A familiar sit-down option where kids, grandparents, and everyone in between can agree on dinner.
Just down the road, Garrettsville’s Pizza Hut balances dine-in comfort with easy carryout and delivery. Thick pan crusts, stuffed crust options, and crowd-pleasing sides like breadsticks and wings make it a straightforward pick for youth teams, birthday outings, or multi-generational family meals. If you’re after a no-surprises experience where everyone knows the menu, this is an easy win.
04
Worth the short drive
Gionino's Pizzeria
Hiram Village, Short Drive West • Northeast Ohio-Style Pizzeria • Best For Hearty, Loaded Pies
A nearby favorite known for substantial pizzas and classic Northeast Ohio comfort fare.
A quick drive over to Hiram lands you at Gionino's, a regional staple for thickly topped, sauce-forward pies. The crust has enough heft to stand up to heavy toppings, making it a smart choice if your crew likes deluxe or meat-loaded combinations. Pair a couple of pizzas with their fried chicken or jojo potatoes and you’ve got an easy spread for a cabin weekend or college get-together.
05
Best for custom pies
Zeppe's Pizzeria
Mantua Village, North Of Garrettsville • Casual Neighborhood Pizzeria • Top Pick For Build-Your-Own Pizza
A flexible, build-it-your-way pizzeria that rewards picky eaters and topping enthusiasts.
Head north to Mantua and Zeppe's offers a comfortable middle ground between chain familiarity and small-town pizzeria charm. The menu invites tinkering, with plenty of topping choices and specialty combinations for when you don’t want to decide. It’s a handy option if your group has mixed tastes and you’re willing to make a short drive for exactly the pizza you want.