01
Classic Cleveland pick
Geraci's Restaurant – Mayfield Village
Wilson Mills Road, Mayfield Village • Old-School Italian-American Pizzeria • Classic Local Favorite
A red-sauce institution turning out thin, crispy pies loaded with toppings in a warm, family-run setting.
Geraci’s has been a go-to for generations of east-siders, and the Mayfield Village location brings that same tavern-style pizza close to Gates Mills. Expect a light, crisp crust, plenty of cheese, and classic combinations like sausage, pepperoni, and banana peppers done exactly the way locals like them. It’s the kind of place where a large pie, antipasto salad, and a booth with family feels just right.
02
Best for wood-fired pies
Crostatas Rustic Pizza
Highland Heights • Wood-Fired Neapolitan Pizzeria • Best For Date Night
A cozy spot known for blistered, wood-fired crusts and thoughtfully topped individual pies.
Crostatas leans into a true Neapolitan style, with a soft, chewy center, charred edges, and simple, high-quality toppings. The menu highlights classics like Margherita alongside seasonal combinations that make the most of fresh ingredients. Pair your pizza with a glass of wine and an appetizer and it turns into an easy, low-key date night not far from the quiet streets of Gates Mills.
03
Build-your-own standout
Master Pizza – Mayfield Heights
Mayfield Heights Strip • Busy Takeout And Delivery Shop • Best For Custom Pies
A local chain favorite where you can build hefty, topping-loaded pies for family takeout or game-day delivery.
Master Pizza has deep roots in the Cleveland area, and the Mayfield Heights location is one of the most convenient options for Gates Mills residents. The crust runs on the thicker side with a satisfying chew, built to hold serious toppings and creative specialty combinations. It’s especially handy when you’re feeding a crowd and want everything from classic pepperoni to spicy specialty pies on one order.
04
Lively neighborhood hangout
Pizzazz on the Circle
University Heights / John Carroll Area • Casual Bar-And-Grill With Pizza • Game-Night Pick
A lively neighborhood spot serving generously topped pizzas alongside wings, salads, and a full bar.
Pizzazz is a staple near John Carroll University, drawing families, students, and longtime locals for its hearty pies and sports-on-TV atmosphere. The crust is classic Cleveland-style—sturdy, golden, and built for sharing—while toppings range from simple cheese to loaded specialty creations. It’s an easy pick when you want pizza, a beer, and a buzzy room that still feels relaxed enough for kids.
05
Upscale local choice
Sara's Place by Gavi's
In The Heart Of Gates Mills • Upscale Bistro With Artisan Flatbreads • Best For Lingering Over Dinner
An elegant village restaurant where elevated flatbreads and pizzas share the spotlight with pastas, seafood, and steaks.
While Sara’s Place is known first for its polished Italian-American menu, the kitchen turns out thoughtful flatbreads and pizza-style dishes that make a refined alternative to a standard pie night. The setting is pure Gates Mills charm, with a cozy interior and a patio that feels tucked away from the city. It’s the spot to choose when you want a good pizza but also crave a proper sit-down dinner with a bottle of wine.