01
Best overall pick
East of Chicago Pizza (Loudonville)
Loudonville, Northwest Of Glenmont • Small-Town Ohio Pizza Chain Shop • Best For Customizable Pies
Reliable stop for thick, cheesy Ohio-style pies after a day on the Mohican trails.
This Loudonville outpost of East of Chicago is one of the closest full-service pizza options to Glenmont, and it leans into the chain’s signature pan and loaded specialty pies. It is an easy call when you want to build-your-own with lots of toppings or feed a carload of campers. Call ahead for carryout on busy weekends around Mohican State Park.
02
Best for big groups
East of Chicago Pizza (Millersburg)
Millersburg, North Of Glenmont • Casual Family Pizza Restaurant • Great For Teams And Gatherings
Plenty of seating and crowd-pleasing pizzas make this an easy choice for groups.
The Millersburg East of Chicago is a go-to when you are bringing the whole crew from a ball game or family get-together. Expect thick, saucy pies, shareable breadsticks, and familiar comfort-food sides that work for mixed appetites. It is a straight shot up the road from Glenmont, so pickup on the way home is simple.
03
Best bar pizza
Bags Sports Pub
Downtown Millersburg • Lively Small-Town Sports Pub • Top Pick For Pizza With A Pint
Crispy, generously topped pies served alongside cold beer and game-day energy.
Bags Sports Pub feels like downtown Millersburg’s living room, and its pizzas are a big part of the draw. The crust comes out crisp around the edges, the toppings are piled on, and the atmosphere is laid-back enough for both locals and visitors in ball caps and hoodies. It is the spot when you want dinner, a game on TV, and a pint in one place.
04
Worth-the-drive classic
Coccia House
Wooster, Northeast Of Glenmont • Old-School Italian Pizzeria • Destination Pie
A long-running Wooster institution known for thick, cheesy trays of pizza.
If you ask around Holmes and Wayne counties for a memorable pizza, Coccia House in Wooster comes up fast. The pies are hearty, with a crust that lands between pan and Sicilian, a rich sauce, and cheese that stretches forever. It is a bit of a drive from Glenmont, but many locals happily make the trip for a Friday or Saturday night splurge.
05
Most familiar option
Pizza Hut (Millersburg)
South Side Of Millersburg • National Pizza Chain Restaurant • Best For Classic Comfort
Exactly the Pizza Hut experience you expect, a short drive from Glenmont.
When you want something predictable and easy, the Millersburg Pizza Hut delivers the same pan, hand-tossed, and stuffed-crust favorites you know. It is convenient for travelers cutting through Amish Country and for families with kids who like to stick to the classics. Order ahead for carryout on your way back toward Glenmont and you will have dinner sorted before you hit the hills.