01
Classic hometown slice
Little Italy Pizza
Glouster Village Center • Old-School Small-Town Pizzeria • Local Institution
A no-frills Glouster staple turning out generous, cheesy pies that feel made for Friday nights at home.
Little Italy is the kind of place where locals have a standing order and the staff knows your usual. The crust is sturdy and lightly crisped, with a classic Ohio-style edge and plenty of cheese over straightforward toppings. It’s the go-to when you want a familiar, comforting pizza without leaving the village.
02
Best for big groups
Ole Time Pizza
South Glouster • Family Carryout And Delivery Shop • Great Value For Families
Hearty, crowd-pleasing pies with thick layers of toppings and sides that make feeding a group easy.
Ole Time leans into big, satisfying portions—think loaded pepperoni, extra cheese, and specialty pizzas designed to fill a table. The menu usually stretches beyond pizza into wings and other comfort food, which works well if not everyone in your group wants the same thing. It’s a reliable choice when you’re feeding a family or a team after a game.
03
Most creative toppings
Avalanche Pizza
East Athens Corridor • Eclectic Artisan Pizzeria • Destination For Foodies
Wildly imaginative pies with bold toppings and chewy, flavorful crust that’s worth the drive from Glouster.
Avalanche is known around Athens County for pushing the envelope, with combinations that go way beyond standard pepperoni and sausage. Expect inventive names, house-made sauces, and crust that actually has character, whether you order whole pies or slices. If you’re making a trip into Athens and want something that feels like a little event, this is the spot to build dinner around.
04
Top late-night option
Goodfella's Pizza
Near Ou Campus In Athens • Walk-Up Slice Counter • Best For Late-Night Slices
A campus-area standby serving oversized, foldable slices that hit the spot after games or concerts.
Goodfella’s sits right in the heart of the student zone, but it also works as an easy grab-and-go stop for anyone passing through uptown Athens. The pizza is classic New York-influenced fare: big, thin slices with crisp bottoms and plenty of cheese, ready under the glass. Swing by when you want something fast, hot, and satisfying without a sit-down meal.
05
Best game-day hangout
Courtside Pizza
Uptown Athens • Casual Sports-Bar Style Pizzeria • Lively Dine-In Pick
Laid-back spot for sharing pizzas, watching the game, and lingering over a pitcher with friends.
Courtside leans into the social side of pizza, with a layout and atmosphere that make it easy to grab a booth and stay a while. The pies are shareable and straightforward—think classic toppings, plenty of cheese, and a crust that holds up well slice after slice. It’s an appealing choice if you’re in Athens for a game, a show, or just want a sit-down option after a drive from Glouster.