01
Best in-town standby
East of Chicago Pizza
In Gnadenhutten Village • Carryout And Delivery Chain Shop • Best For Classic Comfort Pies
Your closest option for dependable, build-your-own pizzas without leaving the village.
This East of Chicago location is the go-to when you want hot pizza fast and do not feel like driving to a bigger town. The menu sticks to the chain’s staples—thick-crust squares, stuffed crust, and a lineup of toppings that cover all the usual bases. It is especially handy for weeknight carryout when you just need reliable, familiar pizza close to home.
02
Small-town favorite
Zifaro's Pizza
Dennison & Uhrichsville Corridor • Small-Town Italian Pizzeria • Top Small-Town Classic
A cozy, no-frills spot locals swear by for hearty pies and generous toppings.
Zifaro's feels like the kind of pizza place every small town hopes to have—friendly, straightforward, and focused on getting the basics right. Expect a slightly thicker crust, lots of cheese, and toppings that come piled on rather than sprinkled. It is an easy pick if you are already in the Dennison/Uhrichsville area for errands or a high school game.
03
Destination pie night
Park Street Pizza
Sugarcreek Countryside • Farm-To-Table Craft Pizzeria • Worth The Scenic Drive
A polished, ingredient-focused pizzeria that turns a pizza run into a night out.
Park Street Pizza is the place you drive a little farther for when you want something beyond standard takeout. The menu leans on quality ingredients, creative specialty pies, and a crisp, well-made crust, with plenty of options for sharing. Pair a visit with a scenic trip through Amish Country and you have an easy, crowd-pleasing evening plan.
04
Family crowd-pleaser
Pizza Hut
Uhrichsville Commercial Strip • Sit-Down National Chain • Best For Families And Teams
A familiar booth-and-buffet style stop that works well for groups and kids.
The Uhrichsville Pizza Hut is a straightforward choice when you are feeding a mix of tastes and ages. Pan, hand-tossed, and stuffed-crust pizzas are all on the board, plus wings and pastas to round things out. It is especially useful after youth sports or school events when you need somewhere everyone already knows and likes.
05
Delivery lifesaver
Domino's Pizza
New Philadelphia Commercial District • Quick-Service Delivery Specialist • Fastest Last-Minute Option
A speed-focused shop for late cravings, big orders, and customizable pies.
Domino's in New Philadelphia is the practical choice when speed and convenience matter more than ambiance. Online ordering and frequent deals make it easy to feed a group without much planning, from basic pepperoni to build-your-own combinations. It is a good backup to keep in mind when other spots are closed or you need pizza on short notice.