01
Best small-town slice
Uncle Al's Pizza
Gomer Along W. Lincoln Highway • General Store Counter Pizza • Small-Town Staple
A classic Gomer stop where you can grab a hot, saucy pie alongside convenience-store essentials.
Tucked into a humble roadside store, Uncle Al's feels as local as it gets for Gomer residents. The pizza leans hearty and straightforward, with plenty of cheese and toppings that go big rather than fussy. It’s the kind of place where you pop in for a quick bite, chat with familiar faces, and leave with dinner sorted.
02
Best family sit-down
Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill
Allentown Road Corridor In Lima • Lively Sports-Bar Pizzeria • Best For Families
A roomy Lima standby with big pizzas, a full menu, and plenty of TVs for game-night gatherings.
About a 15-minute drive from Gomer, Beer Barrel is where many locals head when they want pizza plus a full sit-down meal. The crust is sturdy enough for generous toppings, from classic pepperoni to loaded specialty pies, and there’s a long list of wings, sandwiches, and salads to round things out. It’s loud, casual, and easygoing—ideal for families or larger groups who don’t want to overthink dinner.
03
Best game-day delivery
Fat Jack's Pizza
North Lima Near Harding Highway • Takeout And Delivery Shop • Game-Day Go-To
A local favorite for thick, cheesy carryout pies that can easily feed a hungry crowd.
Fat Jack's is the spot Lima-area regulars turn to when they want a pile of pizza boxes on the table and a big game on TV. The crust is on the thicker side, with a chewy bite that stands up well to extra cheese and toppings. It’s all about reliable, comfort-style pizza that travels well back toward Gomer.
04
Best community-minded carryout
Heavenly Pizza
East Lima Neighborhood • Carryout Pizza With Thick, Airy Crust • Best For Weeknight Pickup
A welcoming carryout shop known for pillowy-crust pies, generous toppings, and friendly service.
Heavenly Pizza has a loyal following thanks to its soft, airy crust and sauce that leans slightly sweet without being heavy. Orders are turned out quickly, making it a dependable option when you’re heading into Lima from Gomer and need dinner squared away. The staff tends to remember regulars, which adds to the small-town feel even in a busier stretch of town.
05
Classic old-school parlor
Leaning Tower of Pizza
Central Lima Near Downtown • Old-School Dine-In Pizza Parlor • Local Classic
A long-running Lima institution serving nostalgic, thin-to-medium pies in a no-rush, old-school setting.
If you like your pizza with a bit of local history, Leaning Tower of Pizza fits the bill. The interior is cozy and unfussy, the pies come out with crisped edges and plenty of flavor, and there’s a steady stream of regulars who’ve been coming for years. It’s a nice choice when you’re willing to drive a bit farther from Gomer for a sit-down meal that feels rooted in Lima’s diner-style past.