01
Best overall pick
Elm's Pizza Parlor
Just Off Downtown Granville • Classic Family Pizza Parlor • Local Favorite
A long-running Granville staple turning out chewy, square-cut pies in a no-frills, everyone-knows-your-name setting.
Elm's is the kind of place where the staff remembers your usual order and the walls tell decades of local stories. The crust is sturdy with a good chew, perfect for their generous toppings and plenty of cheese. It’s the go-to for teams after a game, Denison students in need of comfort food, and families who want an easy, reliably good pizza night.
02
Best neighborhood spot
Joe & Mimi's Pizzeria
River Road, Granville • Casual Small-Town Pizzeria • Best For Takeout
A cozy, low-key shop known for well-topped pies and friendly, quick service that makes carryout a breeze.
Set along River Road, Joe & Mimi’s feels like the kind of place locals quietly guard as “their” pizza spot. Pies lean hearty, with plenty of toppings and a crust that holds up well on the drive home. It’s especially handy for weeknights when you want something better than a chain pizza without a long wait.
03
Best for a night out
Harvest Pizzeria
West Broadway, Granville • Upscale Farm-To-Table Pizzeria • Best For Date Night
Craft pizzas with thoughtful toppings and a polished bar make this the choice when you want pizza and a proper night out.
Harvest Pizzeria brings a more refined feel to Granville’s pizza scene, pairing airy, charred crusts with seasonal toppings and good cocktails. It’s the spot for wood-fired pies topped with things like local sausage, roasted veggies, or drizzle-worthy hot honey. Grab a seat on the patio or near the bar and make an evening of it instead of just grabbing a quick slice.
04
Best for groups
Pizza Cottage
Newark, Off State Route 16 • Lively Family Pizza Restaurant • Best For Big Groups
A roomy, upbeat spot with big-table seating, shareable appetizers, and pizzas built for feeding a crowd.
A short drive from Granville, Pizza Cottage is popular with teams, birthday parties, and families who need space as much as they need a good pie. The menu goes beyond pizza with wings, garlic bread, and salads, so it’s easy to keep everyone happy. Order a couple of large specialty pizzas and let people mix and match slices around the table.
05
Best old-school slice
Plaza Pizza
Central Newark • Old-School Ohio-Style Pizzeria • Classic Carryout Choice
A long-loved Newark shop serving thin, square-cut pizzas that taste straight out of a Friday-night tradition.
Plaza Pizza has the no-nonsense feel of a place that’s been doing one thing well for years: making straightforward, satisfying Ohio-style pies. Expect a thinner crust, edge-to-edge cheese, and toppings cut small so each bite has a bit of everything. It’s an easy detour from Granville when you’re craving a classic carryout pizza with a nostalgic feel.