01
Classic village staple
Elm's Pizza Parlor
Granville Village • Family-Run Pizza Parlor • Old-School Favorite
Thin, square-cut pies and a cozy, no-frills dining room make Elm's a reliable standby right in the village.
Elm's feels like the kind of pizza place every small town hopes it has: family-run, friendly, and focused on the pie. The crust skews on the thinner side with a good crunch, and the toppings are straightforward but generous. It’s an easy choice when you want a classic pizza night close to Granville South, with options for dine-in, carryout, or delivery into the village.
02
Best for takeout night
Joe & Mimi's Pizzeria
River Road Corridor • Casual Carryout Pizzeria • Go-To For Busy Weeknights
Joe & Mimi's turns out hefty, topping-loaded pies that travel well, ideal for takeout back to Granville South.
Tucked along River Road, Joe & Mimi's leans into big flavors and bigger portions, with pizzas built to satisfy a hungry household. The menu offers plenty of classic combinations plus a few heartier specialty pies, along with wings and sides that round out an easy dinner. Parking is simple, service is quick, and the location makes it a convenient stop on the way home from errands in town.
03
Best overall pick
Harvest Pizzeria Granville
South Main Street • Craft Pizza & Cocktails Spot • Destination For Food Lovers
Harvest pairs thoughtfully sourced, wood-fired pies with a polished but relaxed dining room and a strong drink list.
If you’re looking for a night out rather than just a quick slice, Harvest is the standout in easy reach of Granville South. The pizzas highlight seasonal toppings, creative flavor combinations, and a charred, airy crust that appeals to serious pizza fans. With a full bar, small plates, and a patio when the weather cooperates, it works just as well for date night as for a leisurely weekend lunch.
04
Worth the short drive
Plaza Pizza Johnstown
Johnstown • Classic Regional Pizzeria • Thin-Crust Loyalist Pick
Plaza Pizza draws fans from around Licking County for its crisp, edge-to-edge toppings and nostalgic thin crust.
A quick drive west puts you at Plaza Pizza, where the formula hasn’t changed much in decades—and that’s the appeal. Expect a distinctly regional style: cracker-crisp crust, a touch of sweetness in the sauce, and toppings scattered right to the rim. It’s a favorite for larger orders, with pizzas that slice cleanly into party squares and hold up well for sharing back home.
05
Best for big groups
Pizza Cottage
Newark Corridor • Lively Local Chain • Group-Friendly Pick
Pizza Cottage offers crowd-pleasing pies, subs, and salads in a bright, family-friendly setting just a short hop from Granville South.
When you’re feeding a team, extended family, or a group of hungry friends, Pizza Cottage is an easy solution. The crust falls in the middle of the spectrum—not too thin, not too thick—so it works for a wide range of tastes, and the menu stretches comfortably beyond pizza. With plenty of seating and efficient service, it’s the kind of place you can roll into with a crowd after a game or event without much planning.