01
Best overall pick
Adornetto's Selected Italian
Downtown Zanesville • Classic Italian Pizzeria • Enduring Local Landmark
Old-school, family-run Italian spot turning out generously topped pizzas that locals have leaned on for decades.
If you ask around Zanesville for pizza, Adornetto's comes up quickly, thanks to its crisp-yet-chewy crust and hearty, classic toppings. The dining room has a warm, throwback feel that suits lingering over a pie, but they handle big carryout orders well too. It’s the kind of place that works just as well for a casual date as it does for a post-game family dinner.
02
Top small-town slice shop
Tat's Pizzeria
North Zanesville • Cozy Neighborhood Pizzeria • Best For Quick Carryout
A tight, friendly shop known for spot-on crust, well-seasoned sauce, and fast, no-fuss service.
Tat's feels like the kind of no-frills pizza joint every town needs: you call, they remember your favorites, and the pies come out hot and consistent. The crust runs on the slightly thicker side with a good chew, and toppings are piled confidently without being overdone. It’s an easy go-to when you’re heading home from Zanesville and want a reliable box in the back seat before you hit Gratiot.
03
Best for wood-fired pies
Russo's Wood Fired Pizza
South Zanesville • Wood-Fired Artisan Spot • Best For Craft Toppings
Neapolitan-leaning, wood-fired pies with blistered crusts and creative topping combinations in a relaxed dining-room setting.
Russo's leans into the wood-fired style: expect slightly charred edges, soft centers, and toppings that feel more chef-driven than chain-style. Combinations like prosciutto with arugula or spicy sausage with peppers make it a good pick when you want something beyond pepperoni-and-cheese. It’s a comfortable place to sit down with a drink and share a couple of pizzas with friends after a day of exploring the area.
04
Best lake-day choice
Pizza Cottage
Buckeye Lake Shoreline • Lively Lakefront Pizzeria • Best For Groups And Teams
Big-portion pies, lots of seating, and a laid-back vibe make this Buckeye Lake staple ideal for groups coming from all directions.
The Buckeye Lake location of Pizza Cottage is built for gatherings, with roomy tables, plenty of TVs, and a menu that covers everything from loaded specialty pizzas to shareable appetizers. Crusts are sturdy enough to support a heavy hand with toppings, which suits their fully loaded combinations. It’s an easy detour from Gratiot when you want to pair a pizza night with time by the water or need a spot that can handle a crowd without a fuss.
05
Best thin-crust option
Massey's Pizza
South Newark • Columbus-Style Thin-Crust Shop • Game-Day Go-To
Square-cut, cracker-thin pies with edge-to-edge toppings that are perfect for sharing during big games or casual hangouts.
Massey's brings the classic central-Ohio, thin-and-crispy, cut-into-squares style within easy reach of Gratiot. The sauce leans savory, the toppings go all the way to the edge, and the crust stays firm enough to keep slices neat, even when loaded. Order a couple of large specialty pizzas and some wings, and you’ve got a simple, shareable spread for watching the Buckeyes or hosting friends without leaving home for long.