01
Best small-town classic
Pizza Wheel
Woodsfield Main Strip • Small-Town Carryout Pizzeria • Local Standby For Graysville Runs
Go-to spot in Woodsfield for generously topped pies and hearty subs on your way back toward Graysville.
Pizza Wheel feels like the kind of place every rural county seat should have: straightforward, generous, and familiar. The crust is a touch thicker with plenty of cheese, and they do not skimp on toppings, which makes their deluxe and meat pizzas especially popular. It is an easy add-on stop when you are already in Woodsfield for errands and want something everyone back home will be happy to share.
02
Best for sit-down pizza night
Pizza Hut
Woodsfield Shopping Area • Family-Friendly Chain Dine-In • Best For Families
Familiar national chain with reliable pan and stuffed-crust pizzas, ideal when you want table service instead of takeout.
The Woodsfield Pizza Hut is where many Monroe County families end up when they want a simple night out without driving to a bigger city. Classic pan pizzas, breadsticks, and wings keep the menu easy, and the booths make it comfortable to linger over a pitcher of soda. It’s a convenient, predictable choice when you are meeting friends from around the county or celebrating after a local game.
03
Best for loaded specialty pies
DeFelice Bros. Pizza
Downtown New Martinsville • Regional Ohio Valley-Style Pizzeria • Local Favorite
Regional chain known for thickly layered toppings and classic Ohio Valley-style pies just across the river in New Martinsville.
DeFelice Bros. Pizza is a go-to when you want something a bit different from the big national chains, with a crust and topping style locals along the Ohio River know well. Their specialty pizzas come piled high, and combinations like all-meat or veggie supreme are popular for sharing. Pair a pizza with their wings or garlic bread, and the short drive from Graysville feels well worth it.
04
Best for late-night cravings
Domino's Pizza
Route 2 Corridor In New Martinsville • Fast-Delivery Chain Spot • Best For Late-Night Delivery
Fast, customizable chain pizza with reliable delivery windows when you need something hot without much planning.
Domino’s in New Martinsville is built for convenience, whether you are ordering from the app in Graysville or swinging by for carryout on your way home. The ability to fine-tune crusts, sauces, and toppings lets everyone in the group get something they like, from thin-crust pepperoni to heavier specialty pies. It’s especially handy on busy nights when you want predictable delivery times and straightforward pricing.
05
Best for feeding a crowd
Papa John's Pizza
North New Martinsville • Carryout And Delivery Chain • Best For Big Group Orders
Chain favorite with large, shareable pies and sauces that work well for parties, game days, or big family gatherings.
Papa John’s in New Martinsville is a smart pick when you need to feed a lot of people without complicating the order. Their large pizzas, signature garlic butter, and straightforward topping options make it easy to cover both kids’ and adults’ tastes. Place a few mix-and-match orders, add some breadsticks, and the drive back toward Graysville turns into a rolling pizza run for the whole group.