01
Best overall pick
Big City Pizza
Near Central Greenfield • Classic Small-Town Pizzeria • Best All-Around Choice
A friendly, no-frills shop turning out hearty pies that feel made for small-town Friday nights.
Big City Pizza is the spot locals mention first when you ask where to grab a pie in Greenfield. The crust hits that sweet spot between chewy and crisp, with plenty of cheese and toppings piled on generously. It’s an easy choice for carryout on a busy evening, but there’s just enough seating to linger over a pizza and a couple of sides with friends.
02
Classic dine-in parlor
Old Town Pizzeria II
Jefferson Street Corridor • Sit-Down Pizza Restaurant • Relaxed Family Outing
A cozy, old-school pizzeria where the pace is slower and the pies come out hot to the table.
Old Town Pizzeria II feels like the kind of place that’s been part of the weekly routine for years. Hand-tossed pizzas with a slightly thicker crust are the draw, along with shareable appetizers and a laid-back dining room that works well for families and small groups. It’s the spot you pick when you want to sit down, catch up, and let the conversation stretch as long as the cheese pulls.
03
Most dependable delivery
Domino's Pizza
North Washington Street Strip • National Delivery Chain • Go-To For Late-Night And Game Days
A familiar chain that keeps Greenfield covered for fast delivery, customizable pizzas, and late-night cravings.
Domino’s in Greenfield leans into what it does best: consistent pies, quick turnaround, and plenty of deals when you’re feeding a crowd. The build-your-own options and specialty pizzas make it easy to please picky eaters, and the app ordering is handy when you’re already settled in for the game. It’s not fancy, but when you want hot pizza at your door without overthinking it, this is the reliable choice.
04
Quick grab-and-go stop
Hunt Brothers Pizza
Inside A Local Gas Station In Greenfield • Grab-And-Go Counter Pizza • Best For Road-Trip Slices
Convenience-store pizza that’s better than you expect, ideal when you need a hot slice in a hurry.
Hunt Brothers inside one of Greenfield’s gas stations is a small-town staple for people on the move. The pan-style crust is thick and filling, and the “all toppings, one price” setup makes it easy to load up a pizza without doing much math. It’s the kind of place you swing by on your way out to Rocky Fork or after a long shift when cooking at home just isn’t in the cards.
05
Worth-the-drive chain
LaRosa's Pizzeria
Hillsboro, Short Drive South • Family-Friendly Regional Chain • Best Destination Night Out
A regional favorite with a bigger dining room and menu, popular with Greenfield folks willing to make a short drive for pizza night.
For many Greenfield families, LaRosa’s in nearby Hillsboro is the go-to when you want pizza to feel like a night out. The menu stretches beyond pies to include pastas, wings, and salads, so everyone at the table can find something they like. With more seating and a livelier atmosphere than most spots in the village, it’s a natural pick for birthday dinners, team celebrations, or meeting up with friends halfway.