01
Best overall pick
Teaford's Pizza & Subs
Near Downtown Greenville • Independent Pizza And Sub Shop • Local Favorite For Carryout
A small, no-frills spot where locals swear by the hearty pies and loaded subs.
Teaford's feels like the kind of place everyone in town has on speed dial: simple menu, generous toppings, and crust that holds up on the drive home. The specialty and meat-heavy pies are the headliners, but the oven-baked subs and cheesy breadsticks make it easy to feed a crowd. Call ahead on weekend nights, when the carryout rush really kicks in.
02
Classic hometown slice
Don's Pizza
South Greenville • Old-School Local Pizzeria • Best For Nostalgic Pies
A throwback-style pizza joint known for straightforward, comforting pies.
Don's leans into the classic Midwest pizza formula: plenty of cheese, familiar toppings, and a crust that’s sturdy without being too thick. It’s the kind of place where regulars order “the usual” and the staff knows what they mean. If you like your pizza unfussy and reliable, this is a solid stop on the south side of town.
03
Chain with local following
Marco's Pizza
East Main Street Corridor • Fast-Service Pizza Chain • Go-To For Customizable Pies
A popular option for quick, made-to-order pizzas with plenty of topping combos.
Marco’s on East Main is a workhorse for weeknight dinners and last-minute party orders. The crust runs on the heartier side, and the menu has enough specialty pies, calzones, and sides to keep a mixed group happy. Watch for deals on larger orders if you’re feeding a team, study group, or extended family.
04
Family dine-in classic
Pizza Hut
Wagner Avenue Retail Strip • Casual Sit-Down Chain • Best For Family Dinners
A familiar dine-in spot where pan pizzas, breadsticks, and pitchers of soda rule the table.
The Wagner Avenue Pizza Hut is built for groups, with roomy booths, shareable appetizers, and the comfort of a menu everyone already knows. Pan and stuffed-crust pizzas are the big draw, especially for kids and teens. It’s an easy choice when you want to combine pizza night with a relaxed, linger-as-long-as-you-like sit-down meal.
05
Late-night delivery standby
Papa Johns Pizza
East Side Near Us-36 • National Delivery-Focused Chain • Best For Big Group Orders
A dependable choice for hot pies, garlic butter, and wings delivered across much of Greenville.
Papa Johns on East Main is all about convenience: app-based ordering, frequent promos, and quick delivery across town. The pizzas lean cheesy with bold sauces, and the garlic dipping cups are practically mandatory for the crust. When you’re hosting a movie night, game day, or youth group and need several boxes fast, this is a safe bet.