01
Best overall pick
Little Italy Ristorante
Main Street Groveport • Family-Run Italian Restaurant • Local Favorite
A cozy Main Street staple serving generous pies, red-sauce classics, and plenty of neighborhood charm.
If you ask Groveport locals where to sit down for a relaxing pizza dinner, Little Italy is usually the first name that comes up. The crust is sturdy but not heavy, with plenty of cheese and a sauce that leans comforting rather than trendy. It’s the kind of place where you can linger over a pie, a salad, and a glass of wine without feeling rushed.
02
Best for families and teams
Flyers Pizza & Subs
Central Groveport • Local Chain Pizzeria • Great For Groups
Lively, reliable pizza joint known for square-cut Columbus-style pies and easygoing group-friendly service.
Flyers is the go-to spot when you’re feeding a crowd after a game or practice. The pizzas come hot, cut into party squares, with crusts that stay crisp under plenty of toppings. Between the subs, wings, and big dining room, it’s an easy choice for families who want a no-fuss night out close to home.
03
Best for game nights
Massey’s Pizza Sports Bar & Wings
Canal Winchester • Sports Bar And Pizzeria • Game-Day Destination
Thin-crust, edge-to-edge toppings and a full sports-bar setup make this a natural choice for watching the big game.
A quick hop over to Canal Winchester gets you Massey’s, where cold drinks and wall-to-wall TVs meet classic Columbus-style pizza. The crust is cracker-thin and loaded right out to the edge with toppings, ideal if you like a little crunch in every bite. It’s especially popular on weekends, when friends gather for wings, pies, and whatever’s on the big screens.
04
Best takeout standby
Donatos Pizza
Hamilton Road Corridor • Carryout And Delivery Chain • Weeknight Takeout Staple
Dependable thin-crust pies with edge-to-edge toppings, perfect when you want fast, familiar pizza close to Groveport.
For many Groveport households, Donatos is the default weeknight pizza call. The crust is crisp and light, and their trademark edge-to-edge topping style means you rarely hit a bare slice. With quick carryout and delivery from nearby Hamilton Road, it’s ideal when you’d rather stay in than head out to a sit-down spot.
05
Worth-the-drive classic
Plank’s On Parsons
South Side Columbus • Old-School Tavern-Style Pizzeria • Destination Pie
Legendary tavern-style pizza with a slightly sweet crust that loyal fans will happily drive from Groveport to get.
If you’re willing to venture a bit north toward the South Side, Plank’s rewards the trip with one of central Ohio’s most distinctive pizzas. The crust has a faint sweetness and a soft, chewy bite that pairs well with classic toppings and old-school vibes. It’s a laid-back bar setting, making it a fun pick for date night or a casual outing with friends who appreciate a true Columbus classic.