01
Best for quick delivery
Domino's Pizza – New Martinsville
Across The River In New Martinsville • Delivery-First Chain Pizzeria With Custom Builds • Top Choice When You Want Hot Pizza Fast
Reliable, build-your-own pizzas and sides delivered quickly anywhere around Hannibal and New Martinsville.
When you just want an easy pizza night without leaving the house, Domino’s in New Martinsville is the go-to for many Hannibal residents. The menu is broad, with plenty of topping combos, sauces, and crust styles to tweak your order. It’s especially handy on busy weeknights or after a long day on the river when delivery is the priority.
02
Classic dine-in option
Pizza Hut – New Martinsville
New Martinsville Commercial Strip • Sit-Down Chain Pizzeria With Wings And Salad Bar • Best For Family Dinners And Teams
Familiar pan pizzas and wings in a casual dining room that works well for families and groups.
New Martinsville’s Pizza Hut feels like the classic small-town pizza stop: booths, big pitchers of soda, and plenty of space for Little League teams or family get-togethers. The pan and stuffed-crust pies are the main draw, but the wings, pasta, and salads round out the table for mixed appetites. It’s an easy choice when you want to sit down, linger, and let everyone order their own favorites.
03
Budget-friendly pick
Little Caesars Pizza – New Martinsville
New Martinsville Shopping Corridor • Carryout Chain Known For Hot-N-Ready Pies • Best Value For A Quick Grab-And-Go
Fast, inexpensive carryout pizzas ideal for last-minute dinners or feeding a few hungry friends on a budget.
If price and speed matter more than lingering over a long meal, Little Caesars in New Martinsville is tough to beat. The Hot-N-Ready menu means you can usually walk in, grab a pepperoni or cheese pie, and be back in the car in minutes. It’s a popular move for Hannibal locals who need something quick after work, before a game, or on the way back from running errands in town.
04
Closest full-service spot on the Ohio side
Pizza Hut – Woodsfield
Woodsfield Along Oh-78 • Small-Town Dine-In And Carryout Pizza Shop • Good Stop When You’Re Already In Town
A familiar sit-down pizza option right in Monroe County, convenient when errands take you through Woodsfield.
For those who prefer to stay on the Ohio side, the Woodsfield Pizza Hut offers a comfortable, small-town dining room and dependable pies. It’s a natural stop after shopping, ball games, or courthouse business in the county seat. Order a couple of specialty pizzas, add some breadsticks or wings, and you’ve got an easy meal before driving back toward Hannibal.
05
Best for big shareable pies
Fox's Pizza Den – New Martinsville
North End Of New Martinsville • Regional Pizza Shop With Big-Cut Party Pizzas • Great For Feeding A Crowd
Hearty, cut-into-squares pizzas and strombolis that are perfect for parties, game nights, and hungry crews.
Fox’s Pizza Den brings a more regional flavor to the mix, with thickly topped pizzas and signature strombolis that feel built for sharing. The larger sizes and square-cut trays make it easy to feed a group without overcomplicating the order. Many Hannibal and valley residents lean on Fox’s when they’ve got friends over for a big game or need to cover dinner for a crowd without breaking the bank.