For a small village, Hanover sits surprisingly close to some of Licking County’s most satisfying pizza. From no-frills carryouts along OH-16 to family-friendly parlors in nearby Newark, you can find everything from thick, cheesy pies to crisp, foldable slices. This list focuses on the spots locals actually detour for, with notes on what each place does best. Whether you’re grabbing a quick box on the way home or settling in for a sit-down meal, these are the top stops to know.
A reliable stop for generous, classic Ohio-style pies right off OH-16.
Panther Pizza feels like the kind of place you grow up with—thick cheese, sturdy crust, and plenty of toppings for the price. It’s especially handy if you’re coming in or out of Hanover and want to grab a hot box without driving into Newark. Go for a loaded pepperoni or deluxe and add a side of wings if you’re feeding a crowd.
A friendly village spot where you can pair a hot pizza with a scoop of ice cream.
Hanover Pizza and Ice Cream doubles as a pizza joint and dessert stop, making it an easy choice for families or casual meetups. The pizzas lean hearty and straightforward, with plenty of cheese and toppings that appeal to all ages. Plan to linger a bit after your meal so you can finish with soft-serve or a sundae before heading home.
A long-running Newark spot known for thick, cheesy pies and leisurely dine-in meals.
The Incredible Pizza Company is where many locals head when they want more than a quick pickup order. The crust is substantial, the cheese is generous, and the toppings are stacked, making the pizzas feel comfortingly old-school. It’s a good choice when you have time to sit, share a couple of large pies, and let the conversation run long.
A go-to option for consistent delivery pizza with plenty of topping combinations.
Christy’s Pizza has built a steady following in Newark by keeping things consistent—crisp-edged crust, well-seasoned sauce, and toppings that arrive hot and intact. The menu runs from straightforward pepperoni to heavier specialty pies, so it’s easy to keep a mixed group happy. If you’re staying in around Hanover and want pizza to show up at the door, this is one of the safer bets.
A no-frills shop turning out hearty, wallet-friendly pies that feed a group.
Louie’s Pizza keeps things simple: sizable pizzas, straightforward toppings, and prices that make it easy to order one more pie than you think you need. The crust lands in that satisfying middle ground—not too thin, not too thick—with enough structure to hold up under extra cheese. It’s a smart choice when you’re feeding a team after a game or stocking the table for a casual get-together near Hanover.