01
Best overall pick
Mary's Pizza Shop
Lisbon Village Center • Old-School Family Pizza Shop • Local Institution
A Lisbon standby since the early 1960s, known for its distinctive sauce and choice of thin or thick crust.
Mary's is the place longtime Lisbon and Hanoverton families point to when they talk about "pizza night." The menu is straightforward—pies, salads, wings—but the details matter, from the crisped edges on the thin crust to the way the cheese bubbles and browns just right. Expect a steady takeout crowd on weekends and simple, no-fuss seating if you want to eat your pizza hot out of the oven.
02
Best for big groups
Fox's Pizza Den
Lisbon Village Square • Casual Chain Pizzeria • Best For Families And Teams
Hand-tossed pies, party-pleasing sheet pizzas, and plenty of sides make this an easy choice when you are feeding a crowd.
Just off Lisbon’s main drag, Fox’s hits the sweet spot between familiar and customizable, with classic toppings alongside specialty combos. The big "party" and square-cut Sicilian-style pizzas are ideal when you are hauling food back to a gathering in Hanoverton. Add in wings, wedges, and subs, and it is a reliable one-stop shop for game days and birthday parties.
03
Best for quick takeout
Pizza Joe's
North Lisbon • Neighborhood Pizza Counter • Budget-Friendly Favorite
A quick-service spot turning out soft, chewy-crust pizzas and regular specials that are easy on the wallet.
Pizza Joe’s is the kind of place where you can call in an order from the road and be back in Hanoverton with dinner still piping hot. The crust leans soft and bready, with a generous layer of cheese that makes even a basic pepperoni feel indulgent. Daily deals and combo specials are popular with families looking to stretch their pizza budget without skimping on quantity.
04
Best for loaded toppings
Gionino's Pizzeria
East Lisbon • Carryout And Delivery Pizzeria • Topping-Packed Pies And Wings
Hearty, cheese-heavy pizzas and well-seasoned fried chicken make this a go-to for indulgent takeout nights.
Gionino’s is known for going heavy on both cheese and toppings, so a single pie can easily feed a small group back in Hanoverton. The crust has a satisfying chew, sturdy enough to hold piles of sausage, peppers, and extra cheese without going limp. Locals also swear by the JoJo potatoes and fried chicken, which turn a simple pizza order into a full comfort-food spread.
05
Worth-the-drive pick
R Pizza Place
Downtown Columbiana • From-Scratch Family Pizzeria • Destination For Homemade Pies
A family-run shop that builds its pizzas from scratch, with carefully made dough and sauce at the center of every pie.
If you do not mind a slightly longer drive from Hanoverton, R Pizza Place in Columbiana rewards the trip with pizzas that taste distinctly homemade. The crust has character—neither chain-flat nor overly doughy—and the sauce leans savory, complementing classic toppings instead of overpowering them. It is a laid-back spot that works just as well for a casual dine-in meal as it does for a carefully packed takeout order.