01
Best overall pick
Jo-Jo's Original Pizzeria
Oregon – Navarre Avenue Corridor • Old-School Family Pizzeria • Classic Local Favorite
Beloved for its crisp-edged pies, generous toppings, and reliably friendly service.
Jo-Jo’s is the kind of place Oregon families grow up on, with dough that lands right between soft and crisp and toppings piled on without being fussy about it. The classic pepperoni and the loaded deluxe are local staples, and the salads and subs make it easy to feed a mixed crowd. It’s a straightforward spot that shines when you just want a solid pizza and an easy pick-up off Navarre.
02
Best for late-night cravings
Vito's Pizza and Subs
Woodville Road Corridor, Just South Of Harbor View • Casual Carryout And Delivery Shop • Go-To For Late-Night And Game Days
A dependable East Side chain location turning out hearty pizzas and subs well into the evening.
This Vito’s outpost is a handy choice when you’re in Harbor View and want something hot delivered without overthinking it. The thick, cheesy pies, loaded breadsticks, and wings make it a staple for game nights or last-minute gatherings. It’s not fancy, but it’s fast, filling, and consistent, which is exactly what many locals are after.
03
Best for creative slices
Home Slice Pizza
Downtown Toledo – Warehouse District • Lively Slice Shop And Bar • Worth-The-Drive Destination
A downtown favorite known for big New York-style slices, fun topping combos, and a buzzy atmosphere.
If you’re up for a short drive from Harbor View, Home Slice rewards you with foldable slices and a laid-back, downtown vibe. Classics sit alongside more adventurous pies, so it’s easy to try something new without skipping your go-to cheese or pepperoni. It’s an easy add-on before or after a night out in the Warehouse District.
04
Best neighborhood standby
J-Cups Pizza
Central Oregon Neighborhood • No-Frills Takeout Pizzeria • Reliable Weeknight Option
A low-key local shop turning out cheesy, comfort-style pizzas that travel well back to Harbor View.
J-Cups leans into hearty, sauce-forward pies and straightforward combinations that feel tailor-made for a quiet night in. Crusts are sturdy enough to hold up in the box, which is exactly what you want if you’re driving back toward the lake. It’s the kind of place where once you find your favorite combo, you end up ordering it on repeat.
05
Best for deep-dish splurge
PizzaPapalis
Downtown Toledo – Near The Ballpark • Chicago-Style Pizzeria • Sit-Down Spot For Big Appetites
Known for hefty Chicago-style deep dish, this is the place when you want pizza to be the whole event.
PizzaPapalis is a popular choice when friends or family want to make a real outing of pizza night. The deep-dish pies take time but arrive at the table with bubbling cheese, a tangy layer of sauce, and a crust sturdy enough to carve into. Plan ahead, settle in, and treat it as a slow, indulgent meal before wandering through downtown.