01
Classic Grove City institution
Zamarelli's Pizza Palace
Downtown Grove City • Old-School Columbus-Style Pizzeria • Beloved Local Landmark
A longtime Grove City favorite known for crisp, square-cut pies and a comfortable, lived-in feel.
If you ask Grove City locals where they grew up getting pizza, Zamarelli's comes up fast. The crust is thin with just enough chew, the toppings are generous, and the sauce leans classic and comforting rather than trendy. It’s a go-to for carryout on game nights, but the simple dine-in setup makes it easy to linger over a pitcher and a large pie.
02
Best for a laid-back night out
Plank's on Broadway
Historic Broadway In Grove City • Casual Bar-And-Pizza Spot • Great For Groups
Hearty pizzas, a welcoming tavern vibe, and plenty of space to relax right in Grove City's historic core.
Plank's on Broadway feels like a small-town bar in the best way, with pizza that stands on its own. Expect substantial crust, plenty of cheese, and toppings that make one or two slices surprisingly filling. It’s an easy choice when you want pizza plus a beer, a TV game, and a table big enough for the whole group.
03
Family-friendly carryout staple
Flyers Pizza & Subs
Stringtown Road, Grove City • Neighborhood Pizza And Subs Shop • Best For Families And Large Orders
Crowd-pleasing pies, wings, and subs with plenty of size options for everything from weeknights to team parties.
Flyers is the kind of place Harrisburg-area families keep on speed dial for busy evenings. The pizza menu is broad, from classic pepperoni to loaded specialty combinations, and the crust holds up well for takeout and delivery. Add in subs, wings, and salads, and it’s easy to feed a mix of tastes without driving far from the village.
04
West-side Columbus classic
Joseppi's Pizza
Harrisburg Pike, Southwest Columbus • Columbus-Style Carryout Pizzeria • Local Favorite For Takeout
Thin, edge-to-edge pizzas from a long-running west-side brand that keeps things simple and consistent.
Joseppi's on Harrisburg Pike is a practical choice when you want a classic Columbus-style pie without trekking into the city core. The signature move here is the thin crust covered all the way to the edge in toppings and cheese, ideal for people who like every bite to count. It’s especially handy for Harrisburg residents looking for a quick pickup on the way home.
05
Reliable chain with local roots
Donatos Pizza
Grove City Retail Corridor • Thin-Crust Chain Pizzeria • Best For Consistent, Quick Pizza
Familiar thin-crust, edge-to-edge pizza with fast service and easy online ordering for nearby Harrisburg.
With its Grove City location just a short drive from Harrisburg, Donatos is a dependable pick when convenience matters. The crust is characteristically thin and crisp, and the signature edge-to-edge topping style means every slice is loaded. Between the predictable quality and streamlined ordering, it’s a solid option for weeknights when you want dinner handled in one call.