01
Best overall pick
Plank's on Broadway
Grove City Town Center • Lively Tavern With Signature Pizzas • Go-To For A Night Out With Great Pie
Historic tavern vibes and a famously cheesy thin crust make Plank's the Broadway institution that draws Harrisburg locals down 62.
If you want a classic night out built around pizza, Plank's is the obvious move. The crust leans crisp but still foldable, with a generous blanket of cheese and edge-to-edge toppings. Go early for a laid-back family feel, or later when the bar crowd and big pans of pizza take over the room.
02
Classic Columbus-style
Flyers Pizza & Subs
Broadway Strip In Grove City • Counter-Service Columbus-Style Pizzeria • Best For Classic Square-Cut Pies
Flyers turns out textbook Columbus-style pizza: thin, crispy, square-cut, and loaded just right for takeout back to Harrisburg.
This local mini-chain started on the west side and still feels very much like a neighborhood shop. The pies are thin, crackery, and cut into party squares, making them ideal for sharing with a small crowd. Pair a pepperoni and sausage pizza with a sub or garlic bread and you’re set for a low-fuss, high-reward dinner.
03
Family favorite
Tammy's Pizza
Hoover Road Corridor In Grove City • Casual Family Pizzeria • Top Pick For Kids And Big Groups
Tammy's feels like the kind of family-run spot where youth teams, birthday groups, and regulars all pile in for thickly topped pies.
The menu leans familiar—think loaded specialty pizzas, cheesy bread, and big salads—but everything has that small-shop touch. Crusts are sturdy enough to handle heavy toppings, and staff are used to handling large orders without a hitch. It’s a natural choice when you’re hosting a crowd in Harrisburg and want one easy pickup stop.
04
Neighborhood standby
Grandstand Pizza
Residential Grove City Side Streets • No-Frills Carryout Pizza Shop • Perfect For Easy Weeknight Takeout
Grandstand is the straightforward, no-fuss pie shop you call when you want solid pizza and maybe some wings without leaving the neighborhood feel.
This is a classic small carryout place: modest space, friendly counter, and a focus on pizza over frills. The crust lands between thin and hand-tossed, with plenty of cheese and a slightly sweet sauce that wins over kids quickly. It’s close enough to Harrisburg for a quick run when you don’t feel like cooking on a weeknight.
05
Game-day choice
Massey's Pizza Sports Bar & Kitchen
Stringtown Road Retail Corridor • Sports Bar And Pizza Kitchen • Best For Watching The Game Over A Pie
Massey's marries long-running central Ohio pizza traditions with plenty of TVs, cold pitchers, and a menu made for lingering on game day.
Expect crisp-edged, square-cut pies with a slightly old-school feel, plus wings, appetizers, and a full bar. The dining room is laid out with sightlines to multiple screens, so you’re never far from the action. For Harrisburg residents wanting to make Buckeyes or Browns games more of an outing, this is the closest spot that feels like a true sports hangout.