01
Harrod hometown favorite
Wild Mustang Pizza & Wings
In Harrod • Small-Town Pizza And Wings Takeout • Best Overall Pick
Go-to spot in Harrod for hearty, crowd-pleasing pizza and saucy wings.
Tucked right in the village, Wild Mustang is the kind of place locals rely on for easy weeknight dinners and ball-team celebrations. The pizzas are loaded and straightforward, with plenty of toppings and a satisfying, slightly chewy crust. Add in a tray of wings and some sides, and you have an all-purpose takeout order that works for families or a small group of friends.
02
Build-your-own favorite
East of Chicago Pizza
Ada Main Street • Casual Carryout And Delivery Shop • Best For Customizable Pies
A short drive to Ada gets you a flexible menu with different crusts, sauces, and topping combinations.
East of Chicago in Ada is popular with Ohio Northern students and locals who like to tweak their order exactly how they want it. Choose from pan, thin, or loaded Chicago-style crusts, then stack on toppings or try one of their specialty combinations. It is a convenient choice when you need delivery to a gathering or want to feed a mix of picky eaters without a fuss.
03
Budget-friendly classic
Fat Jack's Pizza
East Lima • No-Frills Local Pizza Joint • Best Value Slices
A long-running Lima staple known for generous toppings and fair prices.
Fat Jack's has the feel of an old-school local joint: simple, satisfying pies that put flavor and portion size ahead of frills. The crust is on the thinner side, with edge-to-edge toppings and plenty of cheese, making it ideal for feeding a hungry crew without overspending. It is an easy detour when you are already heading into Lima for errands or a game.
04
Big-group go-to
Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill
West Lima • Lively Sports Bar And Pizzeria • Best For Groups And Game Nights
A bustling spot where big, shareable pizzas meet a full grill menu and plenty of TVs.
Beer Barrel is a Lima-born mini-chain that excels when you need space, variety, and a fun atmosphere. The pizzas are substantial, with options for classic toppings or loaded specialty pies that land in the middle of the table for everyone to share. With burgers, wings, and salads on the menu too, it is a natural pick for mixed groups or watching a Buckeyes game over dinner.
05
Family takeout standby
Padrone's Pizza
North Lima • Neighborhood Pizza And Subs Shop • Best For Family Takeout
Reliable, family-friendly pizza and subs that travel well back to Harrod.
Padrone's offers familiar, comforting pies with a slightly thicker crust and plenty of cheese, along with stromboli, subs, and wings. It is the kind of place where you can call in a big order, swing through Lima, and have everything still hot when you get home. Combo deals and kid-pleasing options make it a smart choice for family movie nights or last-minute gatherings.