01
Best overall pick
Johnnies Villa Pizza
Downtown Johnstown • Old-School Small-Town Pizzeria • Closest Go-To For Hartford Locals
A classic Main Street shop turning out hearty, saucy pies that feel tailor-made for small-town Friday nights.
For many Hartford residents, Johnnies is the default answer when someone says, “Let’s just grab a pizza.” The crust is sturdy enough to handle plenty of toppings, and the sauce leans comforting rather than trendy. It’s the kind of place where staff remembers regulars, and a large pepperoni feeds a hungry crew after a game or a long day in the fields.
02
Best for delivery to Hartford
Plaza Pizza
Newark East Side • Classic Carryout And Delivery Shop • Best For Big Carryout Orders
A local chain known for reliable delivery, generous cheese, and crowd-pleasing pies that travel well back to Hartford.
Plaza Pizza is the workhorse option when you need several boxes on the table fast, whether it’s a birthday party or a last-minute family get-together. The crust is on the thicker side with a satisfying chew, and the toppings are piled on without being fussy. Order a mix of specialty pies and classic pepperoni, and everyone around the table will find something they like.
03
Best game-day hangout
Good Fella'z Pizzeria
Sunbury Town Center • Sports-Bar Style Pizzeria • Best For Watching The Game
A lively spot pairing hefty, cheesy pizzas with a casual bar vibe that makes lingering over the next slice feel natural.
Good Fella'z is the place to go when you want more than just a quick pickup box. The pies are generous, with plenty of cheese and toppings, and the wings and appetizers make it easy to turn dinner into a full evening out. It’s a popular choice for Hartford folks willing to drive a bit for a game on TV, a cold drink, and a hot pizza all in one stop.
04
Best Columbus-style thin crust
Massey's Pizza
New Albany Hamilton Road Corridor • Columbus-Style Thin-Crust Chain • Top Pick For Columbus-Style Cracker Crust
A regional favorite serving tavern-cut, thin-crust pies with edge-to-edge toppings and plenty of crunch.
If you prefer your slices square-cut with a shatteringly crisp crust, Massey’s is worth the drive from Hartford. The signature Columbus-style thin crust is layered with sauce, cheese, and toppings right out to the edge, so every bite feels loaded. Pair a specialty pie with a salad or some garlic bread and you’ve got a solid weeknight or weekend treat.
05
Best family-friendly option
Flyers Pizza & Subs
Pataskala Main Street Strip • Family-Friendly Pizza And Subs Shop • Best For Families With Kids
A casual, kid-friendly spot offering adaptable pies, subs, and sides that make feeding a mixed-ages group simple.
Flyers hits the sweet spot when you’re juggling different tastes and appetites. The pizza crust lands between thin and thick, with plenty of topping combos that keep both kids and adults happy, and the subs are a handy backup for non-pizza eaters. It’s an easy-going, no-pressure stop that Hartford families lean on when nobody feels like cooking.