01
Best overall pick
Bentino's Pizza
Downtown Waynesville • Family-Run Small-Town Pizzeria • Classic Hometown Favorite
A Main Street staple serving crowd-pleasing pies that feel made for small-town Friday nights.
Just a quick drive from Harveysburg, Bentino’s sits right on Waynesville’s main drag and feels like the kind of place locals grow up with. The menu leans into familiar favorites—well-balanced cheese, hearty toppings, and crust that’s sturdy without being heavy. It’s the go-to choice when you want a reliable, old-school pizza night after a day at the lake or the antique shops.
02
Most inventive pies
Roscoe's Pizza
Corwin, Just South Of Harveysburg • Specialty-Pie Focused Pizzeria • Best For Creative Toppings
A local favorite for over-the-top specialty pizzas and big flavors you don’t always find in a village this size.
Roscoe’s feels like a discovery: a laid-back spot in tiny Corwin turning out pizzas loaded with bold topping combinations and plenty of cheese. You’ll find everything from hearty meat-packed pies to fun, offbeat creations that are easy to share with a group. It’s the pick when you’re willing to drive a few extra minutes from Harveysburg for something more adventurous than a standard pepperoni.
03
Fast and familiar
Domino's Pizza
South Main Street, Waynesville • National Delivery Chain • Most Convenient For Carryout And Delivery
Chain comfort with quick service, online ordering, and all the predictable classics.
When convenience matters more than atmosphere, the Waynesville Domino’s is the easy answer for Harveysburg residents. Online ordering, frequent deals, and consistent pies make it a dependable option on busy weeknights or after late games. Opt for carryout on your way home from town, or use it as the backup plan when everyone wants something slightly different, from thin-crust to stuffed bread and wings.
04
Best family outing
LaRosa's Pizzeria
Near Historic Downtown Lebanon • Cincinnati-Style Family Pizzeria • Best For Families And Big Groups
A lively regional chain where big pizzas, shareable appetizers, and kid-friendly service make lingering easy.
About a 20-minute drive from Harveysburg, LaRosa’s in Lebanon is ideal when you’ve got a car full of hungry people. The menu covers the bases with Cincinnati-style pies, baked pasta, calzones, and plenty of sides, so everyone at the table can find something. Pair a pizza run with a stroll through Lebanon’s historic district and it turns into an easy evening out.
05
Worth-the-drive legend
Marion's Piazza
Beavercreek Shopping District • Dayton-Style Thin-Crust Institution • Best Destination Pizza Trip
A Dayton-area icon known for ultra-thin crust, edge-to-edge toppings, and cavernous dining rooms built for a crowd.
Marion’s in Beavercreek is a bit of a drive from Harveysburg, but many locals treat it as a destination in its own right. Pizzas come cut into small squares with generous toppings spread right to the edge, perfect for sharing across a long table. If you’re willing to make a mini road trip, this is the spot that feels like a slice of regional pizza history as much as dinner.