01
Best overall pick
Puckerbrush Pizza
Paulding, About 10 Minutes East Of Haviland • Classic Small-Town Pizzeria • Local Favorite
A longtime Paulding staple known for hearty pizzas and a true small-town crowd.
If you ask people in Haviland where they actually order pizza from, Puckerbrush in Paulding comes up fast. The pies are generously topped, the crust has that just-right chew, and the atmosphere feels like a community living room on busy nights. It is a reliable first choice whether you are grabbing a carryout order or lingering over a casual dinner with the family.
02
Best road-trip slice
Puckerbrush Pizza
Continental, Northeast Of Haviland • Takeout-Focused Hometown Shop • Worth The Drive
A second Puckerbrush outpost that keeps the same generous portions and small-town friendliness.
For folks on the north side of Haviland or heading toward Continental, this Puckerbrush location is an easy add-on to an afternoon errand run. The menu mirrors the Paulding shop, so you can expect familiar specialty pies and plenty of cheese. Call ahead, swing through town, and you are back on the road with hot pizza in the passenger seat.
03
Best for familiar classics
Pizza Hut
Paulding, Along Us-127 • Family-Friendly National Chain • Best For Families
A go-to option when you want the comfort of a familiar menu and easy group ordering.
This Paulding Pizza Hut is a standby for busy weeknights, birthday parties, and post-game team meals. Pan pizzas, stuffed crust, and wings make it simple to keep a crowd happy, and the predictable menu appeals to picky eaters. It is especially handy if you are coordinating a larger order from Haviland and need online ordering and standard chain deals.
04
Best quick stop
Little Caesars
Van Wert, East Side • Budget-Friendly Carryout Chain • Quick Carryout Option
Grab-and-go pizzas that make sense when you are passing through Van Wert and need dinner fast.
If you are already in Van Wert for shopping or errands, Little Caesars is the easiest way to bring a stack of pizzas back to Haviland without much planning. The Hot-N-Ready model means you can usually walk in and walk out in a few minutes. It is not a lingering dine-in experience, but it is hard to beat for feeding a group on short notice.
05
Best for late-night delivery
Domino's Pizza
Van Wert, Near Us-30 • Modern Delivery-Focused Pizzeria • Game-Day Favorite
A delivery-oriented option with lots of toppings, sides, and tracking for bigger game-night orders.
Van Wert's Domino's is the pick when you want to build out a full spread of pizzas, wings, bread twists, and desserts. The menu is highly customizable, and the app-based ordering and tracking appeal to anyone who likes to keep tabs on their food. For sports nights or movie marathons where variety matters as much as the pizza itself, this is the spot locals turn to.