01
Best overall pick
Pizza Crossing
Historic Downtown Logan • Bustling Dine-In And Carryout Pizzeria • Local Legend
Beloved small-town spot serving hefty, topping-loaded pies that are worth the short drive from Haydenville.
If you ask around Haydenville or Logan where to get pizza, this is the name you hear first. The crust strikes a nice balance between crispy edge and chewy center, and the specialty pies are packed enough to feed a cabin full of hikers. Go early on weekend nights, when the dining room and carryout line both fill up fast.
02
Best for easy pickup
Cristy's Pizza
West Logan • Carryout And Delivery Pizza Shop • Best For Delivery And Takeout
Fast, reliable pies with plenty of topping choices and a setup made for quick runs from nearby cabins.
Cristy's is the go-to when you want hot pizza without lingering in town. The menu leans classic—pepperoni, deluxe, and loaded meat options—but the crust is sturdy enough to travel well back to Haydenville or a Hocking Hills rental. Add wings and cheesy bread if you are feeding a bigger group and want everything in one stop.
03
Most playful vibe
Captain Ron's Pirate Pizza
Lake Logan Area • Lakeside, Pirate-Themed Pizzeria • Best For Lakeside Hangs
Casual, pirate-themed stop by the water serving shareable pies that pair well with a day on Lake Logan.
Captain Ron's is the fun choice when your day includes kayaks, pontoon boats, or a lakeside stroll. The pizzas skew thinner and easy to split, with familiar toppings and a relaxed, vacation-town feel. It is an especially good fit for families or groups who want something easygoing and a little different from the usual strip-mall shop.
04
Classic sit-down parlor
Papa Dino's Pizzeria
Logan Town Center • Old-School Small-Town Pizza Parlor • Best For Sit-Down Family Meals
Cozy, no-frills pizzeria known for generous cheese, friendly staff, and a laid-back dining room.
Papa Dino's feels like the kind of place locals have been going to for decades, with roomy booths and a steady takeout trade. The pizzas come loaded, especially the classic pepperoni and sausage combinations, and the menu stretches into subs and pasta if someone in the group wants more than a slice. It is a good call when you want to sit down in town before heading back toward Haydenville for the night.
05
Hearty comfort choice
Little Italy Pizza
Logan East Side • Casual Italian-American Pizzeria • Best For Big, Shareable Meals
Hearty pies and Italian comfort dishes that easily feed hungry groups coming off the trails.
Little Italy leans into classic comfort food: thickly topped pizzas, baked pastas, and plenty of cheese. It is a smart option if you have a mixed group of pizza fans and pasta people, or if you want leftovers to take back to a cabin fridge. The portions are generous, making it an excellent value for families or friends staying near Haydenville.