01
Best overall pick
Farmhouse Parlor & Grill
Downtown Hayesville • Small-Town Family Restaurant • Best Overall Pizza
Hometown favorite on Main Street with generously topped pies and a cozy, all-ages feel.
Farmhouse Parlor & Grill is the kind of place where the staff tends to recognize regulars, and the pizzas come out with a bubbling, cheese-heavy top and a sturdy crust. Classic pepperoni and meat-heavy pies are the go-to, but the menu also covers subs, wings, and ice cream so everyone at the table can find something. It is the easiest choice when you want a relaxed sit-down pizza night without leaving the village.
02
Destination slice
Holy Pepperoni
Ashland – Cleveland Avenue Corridor • New Haven-Style Apizza Shop • Worth The Drive
Serious, charred-crust apizza in Ashland that rewards anyone willing to drive a few extra miles from Hayesville.
Holy Pepperoni leans into New Haven-style apizza, with thin, chewy crusts that pick up just enough char from the hot oven. Toppings skew creative as well as classic, so you can stick with a crisp pepperoni pie or branch out into specialty combinations that rotate with the seasons. It is the spot to choose when you are craving something a little more destination-worthy than standard carryout.
03
Delivery standby
Domino's Pizza
Ashland – Claremont Avenue • National Delivery Chain • Best For Fast Delivery
A reliable delivery workhorse with lots of crust options, sauces, and late-night ordering from just up the road in Ashland.
When you are in Hayesville and just want pizza to show up at the door, Domino's in Ashland is usually the fastest answer. The menu is built for customization, from hand-tossed to thin crust and stuffed options, plus a long list of toppings and sauces. It is a practical pick for game nights, cabin stays, or feeding a crowd without much advance planning.
04
Familiar favorite
Pizza Hut
Ashland – Shopping Strip • Sit-Down Chain Pizzeria • Best For Family Dine-In
Classic pan and stuffed-crust pies in a casual dining room that still feels built for teams, birthdays, and family meetups.
Ashland's Pizza Hut offers the comfort of a familiar menu, from thick, buttery pan pizzas to stuffed crust and loaded specialty pies. The roomy booths and easygoing atmosphere make it an obvious stop after practices, tournaments, or shopping runs in town. If you want a predictable, kid-friendly pizza night within a short drive of Hayesville, this is a dependable choice.
05
Post-hike pie stop
East of Chicago Pizza
Loudonville • Casual Buffet-Friendly Chain • Great After Outdoor Adventures
Flexible buffet-style and build-your-own pies that are especially satisfying after a day on the Mohican trails near Loudonville.
East of Chicago in Loudonville is a natural add-on if you have spent the day around Mohican State Park and want to refuel before heading back toward Hayesville. The crust leans thick and hearty, with plenty of sauce and cheese, and the buffet or build-your-own options make it easy to keep a mix of kids and adults happy. It is the kind of low-fuss, high-carb stop that fits perfectly between hiking boots and a quiet drive home through the countryside.