01
Best overall pick
Plaza Pizza
South Side Near 30Th Street • Family-Friendly Local Pizzeria • Local Favorite For Classic Ohio-Style Pies
Old-school square-cut pies with plenty of cheese make this a natural go-to for families on the south side of town.
Plaza leans into central-Ohio tradition with thin, crispy crust, edge-to-edge toppings, and a straightforward, no-gimmicks menu. It’s an easy stop before or after errands along 30th Street, and regulars swear by the pepperoni and sausage combos. Expect a steady stream of carryout orders, but the crew keeps things moving and the pizzas come out consistently hot.
02
Best for game day
Massey’s Pizza Sports Bar & Wings
Hebron Road Near Indian Mound Mall • Lively Sports Bar With Columbus-Style Pizza • Best For Groups And Big Games
Crisp, cornmeal-dusted crust and plenty of TVs make this the spot when you want pizza with a side of sports.
Massey’s is where Heath locals head when they want a pepperoni-loaded, Columbus-style pie and a game on in the background. The menu runs deep with wings, subs, and appetizers, so everyone at the table can find something. It’s especially popular on Buckeyes and NFL Sundays, when the energy is high but the service still stays attentive.
03
Weeknight standby
Donatos Pizza
Central Heath On Hebron Road • Ohio Chain Known For Thin, Crispy Crust • Reliable Family Takeout
Edge-to-edge toppings, quick service, and familiar flavors make this Donatos a dependable choice when no one wants to cook.
This Hebron Road Donatos hits the sweet spot between convenience and consistency, especially on busy weeknights. The hallmark here is ultra-thin crust cut into small squares, loaded right out to the edges with toppings. It’s easy to order a couple of large pizzas and let everyone graze, whether you’re feeding kids after practice or hosting friends for a low-key evening in.
04
Best for thick crust
Jet’s Pizza
Hebron Road Strip • Casual Carryout Spot For Detroit-Style Pizza • Hearty Delivery And Carryout Pick
Square, cheesy deep-dish pies with buttery corners and bold crust flavors make this the move when you’re craving something substantial.
Jet’s in Heath is all about the pan-baked, Detroit-style experience: tall, airy crust, caramelized edges, and generous cheese. You can customize everything from the sauce level to the flavored crust, so it’s easy to dial in your ideal pie. It’s primarily a carryout and delivery operation, perfect for those nights when you just want a big, comforting pizza to share on the couch.
05
Best small-shop gem
Pick-Up Pizza
East Heath Neighborhood Spot • No-Frills Carryout Pizzeria • Value-Friendly Local Favorite
Generous toppings, fair prices, and quick counter service make this tiny shop a handy option for locals in the know.
Pick-Up Pizza feels like the kind of place that’s been quietly feeding the neighborhood for years: simple setup, friendly staff, and pies that travel well. The crust lands in that sweet middle ground—not too thick, not too thin—with plenty of cheese and toppings for the price. Call ahead on weekend evenings, as the ovens stay busy and regulars tend to place bigger orders.