01
Best overall pick
Hometown Pizza
In The Village Center • Family-Run Pizzeria And Italian Joint • Local Favorite For Classic Pies
The place most Hicksville locals name first when you ask where to grab a dependable pizza.
Hometown Pizza leans into generous toppings and a cozy, no-rush feel that works just as well for dine-in as for carryout night at home. The crust lands in that sweet spot between soft and crisp, with well-seasoned sauce and plenty of cheese. It’s the kind of spot where ordering your “usual” quickly becomes a habit.
02
Best for big toppings and value
Red Angel Pizza
West Side Of Hicksville • Carryout And Delivery Pizza Shop • Great For Feeding A Crowd
Red Angel is the go-to when you want hefty, topping-loaded pies that can cover a whole team or family gathering.
Known for its generous portions, Red Angel Pizza is where locals call when they need multiple pizzas without breaking the budget. Specialty combinations and thick layers of cheese make even the basic pepperoni feel like an upgrade. Expect a straightforward counter-service operation focused on getting hot boxes out the door fast.
03
Best for a quick family dinner
Palace Pizza
East Hicksville Strip • Small-Town Sit-Down Pizzeria • Easy Weeknight Choice
Palace Pizza offers simple, well-made pies and a relaxed setting that suits families and small groups.
With a compact dining area and friendly service, Palace Pizza is ideal when you want to sit down for a low-key meal without leaving town. The menu sticks to familiar favorites—think meat lovers, veggie, and cheese bread—executed consistently. It’s a reliable option for those nights when cooking just isn’t in the cards.
04
Worth-the-drive option
Mancino's Pizza & Grinders
In Nearby Defiance • Pizza And Grinder Shop • Best Combo Of Pizza And Sandwiches
Mancino’s in Defiance is popular with Hicksville-area folks who want both a solid pizza and a hot grinder in one stop.
About a short drive east, Mancino’s offers a slightly thicker, chewy crust and a menu full of toasted grinders that pair nicely with a shared pizza. It’s a sensible choice when you’re already in Defiance running errands or catching a game. Large portions and plenty of topping choices make it easy to split a few items across the table.
05
Game-night takeout favorite
Padrone's Pizza
In Nearby Antwerp • Small-Town Takeout Pizzeria • Best For Quick Carryout
Padrone’s in Antwerp is a convenient option for crisp-edged pies on the way home from the highway.
Located north of Hicksville, Padrone’s is a familiar local chain that focuses on speedy carryout and delivery-style pizzas. The crust bakes up on the crisp side, with plenty of edge-to-edge toppings and a slightly sweet sauce that appeals to kids and adults alike. It’s a natural stop when you’re passing through Antwerp and want a hot box in the car within minutes.