01
Best overall pick
Pizza Crossing
Downtown Logan • Lively Hometown Pizzeria • Classic Local Favorite
A bustling Logan mainstay turning out generously topped pies that have become a road-trip ritual for many Hocking Hills visitors.[1][6]
Just up the road in downtown Logan, Pizza Crossing is the name you’ll hear most often when locals talk about their go-to pie.[1][6] The crust strikes a balance between chewy and crisp, the toppings come piled on, and the menu covers everything from classic pepperoni to hearty specialty combinations that easily feed a cabin full of friends.[1] Expect a busy dining room at peak times, but the service is practiced and takeout is dialed in for grab-and-go nights back at Hide-A-Way Hills.[1][6]
02
Best for easy takeout
Cristy's Pizza
West Logan • Casual Takeout And Delivery Shop • Best For Big Groups
A reliable West Logan spot known for fast service, crowd-pleasing pizzas, and plenty of portions for hungry cabins.[3][5]
Cristy’s Pizza on West Hunter Street gives you a straightforward, no-drama option when you want hot pizza with minimal planning.[3] The menu leans toward classic Midwest comfort—think thick layers of cheese, meaty toppings, and shareable sides like breadsticks and wings that make feeding a big group simple.[3] It’s especially handy if you’re staying near Hide-A-Way Hills and want an easy pickup or delivery-style experience without heading into downtown Logan’s busier strip.[3][5]
03
Most playful pick
Capt. Ron's Pirate Pizza
Lake Logan Marina Area • Seasonal Lakefront Pizza Stand • Fun Stop After The Water
A quirky, pirate-themed spot near Lake Logan serving pizza to boaters, paddlers, and anyone making a day of the water.[4][5]
Capt. Ron’s Pirate Pizza leans into the lake-life vibe, turning out pies for boaters and beachgoers near Lake Logan.[4][5] It’s more laid-back than a sit-down restaurant, but that’s the charm—order a simple pepperoni or a loaded specialty pizza, then eat dockside or haul it back to the cabin after a day on the water.[4] If you want a slice that feels like part of the Hocking Hills vacation experience, this is an easy, memorable stop.[4][5]
04
Best small-town stop
Papa Dino's Pizzeria
Laurelville Village • Small-Town Sit-Down Pizzeria • Best For A Post-Hike Meal
A cozy Laurelville favorite that pairs well with hikes in the southern Hocking Hills, serving hearty pies and other homestyle staples.[4][5]
If your day takes you toward the Laurelville side of Hocking Hills, Papa Dino’s makes a natural place to refuel.[4][5] The vibe is small-town friendly, with thick, satisfying pizzas, simple pasta dishes, and subs that work just as well for dine-in as they do for takeout back to Hide-A-Way Hills.[4] It’s the kind of low-key, consistent spot you appreciate after tackling nearby trails and scenic drives.[4][5]
05
Coziest comfort pick
Little Italy Pizza
South Logan • Old-School Italian-American Spot • Comforting, No-Frills Pick
A classic Logan pizzeria with an unfussy, homey feel and plenty of cheesy, saucy comfort on the menu.[4][5]
Little Italy Pizza is the kind of place where the focus is squarely on hearty, familiar pies rather than trend-chasing toppings.[4][5] Expect a straightforward lineup of pizzas, stromboli, and other Italian-American staples that travel well if you’re taking dinner back toward Hide-A-Way Hills.[4] It’s a solid choice when you want something filling and comforting after a long day exploring caves, waterfalls, and back roads.[4][5]