01
Best overall pick
Giovanni's Pizza
Hillsboro – North High Street • Classic Italian-American Pizzeria • Local Favorite
Go-to spot for generous, comforting pies and a small-town, everyone-knows-everyone feel.
Giovanni's is the kind of place Highland-area families have been calling for years when they want a solid, no-fuss pizza night. The crust is substantial without being heavy, and toppings tend to be piled on with a generous hand. It’s an easy choice when you want a dependable pie that tastes like the local standard.
02
Best for a small-town slice experience
Big Ernie's Pizza
Hillsboro – Just Off The Downtown Strip • Old-School Takeout Joint • Best For Big Flavors On A Budget
A no-frills shop known for hearty, well-topped pizzas that don’t skimp on cheese.
Big Ernie's feels very much like a Hillsboro original, with straightforward pies that focus on chewy crust, plenty of sauce, and lots of cheese. The menu leans toward classic combinations, which makes it easy to keep everyone at the table happy. It’s a smart pick when you’re heading back to Highland and want plenty of food for the money.
03
Best for family dinners
LaRosa's Pizzeria
Hillsboro – Shopping Corridor • Family-Friendly Regional Chain • Best For Family Dinners
Cincinnati-born chain bringing shareable pies, pastas, and a kid-friendly vibe to Hillsboro.
LaRosa's gives Highland-area families a broad menu, so the pizza lovers and pasta fans can all eat well in one stop. The crust leans toward the classic LaRosa’s style—on the thinner side, with a slightly sweet sauce that regulars swear by. Booth seating and familiar chain conveniences make it an easy meet-up spot before or after local games and events.
04
Best for late-night delivery
Domino's Pizza
Hillsboro – East Side • Delivery-Focused National Chain • Best For Late-Night Delivery
Fast, customizable pizza with the tracking and timing that make last-minute orders painless.
When you’re back in Highland and don’t feel like leaving the house again, Domino’s is the reliable delivery option many locals lean on. The menu covers everything from classic hand-tossed pies to specialty combinations, plus wings, breads, and dessert extras. It’s especially handy for late evenings when smaller mom-and-pop shops have already closed.
05
Best sit-down chain option
Pizza Hut
Hillsboro – Main Highway Corridor • Sit-Down National Pizza Chain • Reliable Dine-In Option
Familiar pan and hand-tossed pizzas served in a comfortable, family-oriented dining room.
The Hillsboro Pizza Hut is a straightforward choice when you want classic pan pizza and a booth to settle into. Between the customizable crusts, well-known specialty pies, and crowd-pleasing sides, it’s an easy answer for mixed groups or visiting relatives. Its location along the main drag makes it a convenient stop on the way back toward Highland or after a run into town.