01
Best overall pick
Crostatas Pizzeria
Bishop Road Corridor • Neapolitan Thin-Crust Trattoria • Upscale Night Out
Wood-fired pies, silky mozzarella, and a tight Italian menu make Crostatas the place to linger over pizza and a glass of wine.
Crostatas feels more like a small Italian trattoria than a typical suburban pizzeria, with an open kitchen and a cozy, brick-accented dining room. The focus is on Neapolitan-style pies with blistered, chewy crusts, fresh toppings, and classics like Margherita done right. It is the choice when you want pizza to feel like an evening out rather than just a quick bite.
02
Neighborhood standby
Zeppe's Pizzeria Highland Heights
Wilson Mills Road Strip • Classic Carryout And Delivery Shop • Weeknight Convenience Hero
Generous toppings, familiar flavors, and fast service make Zeppe's a go-to for easy pizza nights in Highland Heights.
Zeppe's is the kind of place locals keep on speed dial for last-minute dinners and casual get-togethers. The menu leans into crowd-pleasing, classic pizzas with plenty of topping choices, plus wings, subs, and other easy add-ons for a full spread. It is especially handy when you need to feed a group without overthinking the order.
03
Best for families
Romeo's Pizza Highland Heights
Wilson Mills Retail Strip • Family-Friendly Regional Chain • Kid-Pleasing Choice
Sweet-leaning sauce, loaded specialty pies, and value-focused combos make Romeo's a natural fit for family pizza night.
Romeo's puts its stamp on classic pizza with a slightly sweet sauce and hearty, edge-to-edge cheese coverage that kids and adults both latch onto. The specialty lineup ranges from meat-heavy creations to veggie-forward pies, and there are usually deals that make multi-pizza orders affordable. It is an easy pick when you are juggling different tastes around the table.
04
Old-school favorite
Pizza Roma
Som Center Road, South Of Highland Heights • Old-School Takeout Joint • Sauce-First Traditionalist Pick
A no-frills counter spot turning out square-cut, slightly thicker pizzas that taste like the classic Cleveland-style pies many locals grew up on.
Pizza Roma is all about straightforward, nostalgic pizza—think sturdy crust, flavorful sauce, and pies cut into easy-to-share squares. The space is modest and geared toward takeout, but the menu also covers subs and a few other basics for a low-key meal. It is the place you call when you want something unpretentious that hits the same way every time.
05
Worth-the-drive option
Master Pizza – Mayfield Heights
Nearby Mayfield Heights • Award-Winning Modern Pizzeria • Best For Specialty Pies
A short hop from Highland Heights, Master Pizza is known for competition-winning dough and creative topping combinations that reward repeat visits.
This Mayfield Heights outpost draws pizza fans from surrounding suburbs with a menu that goes beyond basic pepperoni. Expect thoughtfully balanced specialty pies with crisp-yet-chewy crusts, from spicy options to loaded white pizzas and everything in between. It is an excellent choice when you are in the mood to try something new or build a more ambitious game-day order.