01
Best for watching the game
Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill
East Hilliard Near Mill Run • Lively Sports-Bar Pizzeria • Best For Groups And Game Days
Big, crowd-pleasing pies, plenty of TVs, and a long beer list make this the go-to Hilliard pick for pizza and sports.
Beer Barrel brings an energetic, family-friendly sports-bar feel, with pizzas built for sharing and enough screens to keep every fan happy. Expect generous toppings, thick-cut pepperoni, and a crust that holds up well under loaded combinations. It’s an easy choice when you want dinner, drinks, and the game all in one place.
02
Classic local favorite
Flyers Pizza Hilliard
Roberts Road Corridor • Classic Columbus-Style Pizzeria • Neighborhood Standby For Carryout
Thin, square-cut Columbus-style pies with edge-to-edge toppings have made Flyers a reliable Hilliard staple for years.
Flyers leans into local tradition with cracker-thin crust, a slightly sweet red sauce, and toppings that run right to the edge. The menu covers all the basics—pepperoni, deluxe, veggie—plus subs, salads, and wings that travel well. It’s the spot locals call for weeknight carryout, team parties, and low-fuss pizza nights.
03
Best pizza-and-pub combo
Grandad's Pizza & Pub - Hilliard
Old Hilliard Historic District • Laid-Back Pizza Pub • Best For Casual Nights Out
Hearty pies, cold beer, and a cozy pub atmosphere make Grandad’s feel like a true neighborhood hangout.
Grandad’s does the comfort-pub formula well: substantial pizzas, friendly service, and plenty of local regulars. The specialty pies are loaded, with combinations like classic supreme-style toppings or meat-heavy builds that pair nicely with a draft beer. It’s a strong pick for lingering over a pie while you catch a game or meet up with friends in Old Hilliard.
04
Best for variety and custom orders
Cottage Inn Pizza Hilliard
Cemetery Road Strip • Carryout And Delivery Specialist • Go-To For Big Orders
Multiple crust options, build-your-own pies, and efficient service make Cottage Inn ideal when you’re feeding a crowd.
Cottage Inn stands out for its range of crusts and sauces, from classic round to deep dish and more specialty-leaning options. The menu is built for customization, so it’s easy to satisfy mixed preferences or accommodate dietary needs in one big order. With a focus on carryout and delivery, it’s a dependable choice for office lunches, team dinners, or hotel-room pizza nights near Hilliard.
05
Most creative toppings
Romeo's Pizza - Hilliard
South Hilliard Near Hilliard-Rome Road • Creative Chain Pizzeria • Best For Late-Night Cravings
Thicker, doughy crust and bold topping combinations give Romeo’s a slightly different spin from the typical Columbus-style slice.
Romeo’s leans into big flavor, with a sweeter sauce, plenty of cheese, and specialty pies that pile on meats, veggies, or both. It’s a smart move when you’re in the mood to branch out beyond the standard pepperoni and sausage routine. Online deals and convenient hours make it especially handy for later-evening takeout on the south side of Hilliard.