01
Historic tavern favorite
Sunrise Inn of Warren
Courthouse Square, Warren • Classic Italian Tavern With Brier Hill Pizza • Best Overall Pick
A Warren landmark known for its square Brier Hill pies, crispy wings, and lively neighborhood feel.
Sunrise Inn has been a go-to in downtown Warren for generations, and it’s the place locals mention first when you ask where to start. The Brier Hill pizza—with thick crust, rich sauce, peppers, and plenty of cheese—captures a Mahoning Valley classic, but the menu runs deep with wings and tavern staples. It’s a busy spot on weekends, so calling ahead or planning for a wait is wise.
02
Old-school downtown slice
Avalon Downtown Pizzeria
Downtown Warren Riverfront • Thin-Crust Pizzeria With A Bar-Style Vibe • Best For Classic Pies
Straightforward, well-topped pizzas served in a relaxed, no-frills downtown storefront.
Avalon leans into the old-school pizza parlor experience, with foldable slices, crisp edges, and generous toppings. It’s a strong pick when you want a simple pepperoni or sausage pie done right without a lot of fuss. Grab a booth with friends or call ahead for carryout before heading back toward Hilltop.
03
Loaded carryout favorite
Ianazone's Pizza (Warren)
West Warren Corridor • Carryout And Delivery Pizza Shop • Best For Takeout
Hearty, topping-heavy pizzas and party trays ideal for game nights and family gatherings.
Ianazone’s is a regional staple, and the Warren shop is a convenient call from Hilltop when you need pizza delivered. The crust runs on the thicker, chewier side, built to hold serious amounts of cheese, pepperoni, and specialty toppings. Add on wings or JoJo potatoes and you have an easy crowd-pleaser for a full house.
04
Sit-down Italian pick
Salvatore's Italian Grill (Howland)
Howland Township • Casual Italian Grill With Brick-Oven Pizzas • Best For Dine-In
A family-friendly grill where you can pair crisp-edged pizzas with pasta, salads, and a glass of wine.
Salvatore’s fits nights when pizza is part of a slower, sit-down meal rather than a quick grab-and-go. Their pies have a firmer, crisper crust and a range of toppings, from classic pepperoni to more dressed-up combinations. It’s a comfortable option for mixed groups where not everyone wants pizza but you definitely do.
05
Regional chain standout
Cocca's Pizza (Niles/Howland)
Niles And Howland Line • Neighborhood Takeout Shop With Thick-Crust Pies • Best For Big Appetites
Square-cut, sauce-forward pizzas with a doughy, satisfying crust that travel well back to Hilltop.
Cocca’s brings a Youngstown-area style of pizza to the Niles and Howland corridor, making it an easy stop when you’re out running errands. Expect substantial, cheese-blanketed pies that hold up nicely for the drive home. The value is strong, especially if you’re feeding a larger group or looking to stretch leftovers into the next day.