01
Best overall pick
Gionino's Pizzeria
Hiram Village Center • Classic Northeast Ohio Pizzeria • Go-To Local Favorite
A small Hiram shop turning out consistently good pies that students and locals rely on for easy takeout and delivery.
Gionino's is the most obvious choice when you want pizza without leaving Hiram, and it earns that spot with sturdy crusts, generous cheese, and plenty of topping combos. The menu runs from basic pepperoni to specialty options like chicken or loaded-meat pies, plus wings if you are feeding a crowd. It is a straightforward, no-frills operation where hot, reliable pizza is the main draw.
02
Most reliable delivery
Domino's Pizza
State Street Strip In Garrettsville • Fast-Delivery Chain Shop • Best For Late-Night Delivery
This Garrettsville Domino's is the workhorse option for quick, trackable delivery to Hiram and the surrounding back roads.
If you care more about speed and predictability than atmosphere, Domino's on State Street gets the job done. The app ordering and order tracking make it easy for students or busy families to time a delivery or pickup run. Stick with their classic hand-tossed or thin crust, and take advantage of mix-and-match deals when you need to feed a group on a budget.
03
Family-friendly chain option
Pizza Hut
Retail Cluster By State Street, Garrettsville • Sit-Down And Carryout Chain • Best For Families And Groups
A familiar Pizza Hut outpost where pan pizzas, breadsticks, and shareable meals make it easy to feed a table full of people.
Garrettsville’s Pizza Hut is the comfortable choice when you have kids in tow or want a familiar menu everyone recognizes. The classic pan crust is the star here—thick, buttery, and built to hold lots of toppings—backed up by wings, pasta, and plenty of sides. It is an easy meet-in-the-middle spot for families coming from different corners of Portage County.
04
Hearty neighborhood standby
Guido's Pizza & Catering
Downtown Garrettsville • Homey Small-Town Pizza Joint • Best For Hearty Slices And Subs
A long-running local shop known for thickly topped pies, loaded subs, and straightforward, small-town service.
Guido's leans into comfort-food territory, with pizzas that come out cheesy and filling rather than fussy or trendy. Locals like it for meaty specialty pies and substantial subs, especially on game nights or after local events. Call ahead for takeout during peak dinner hours, as the kitchen can get busy when the town does.
05
Game-day crowd pleaser
Zeppe's Pizzeria
Mantua Village Corridor • Carryout-Focused Local Chain • Best For Big Game-Day Orders
Mantua’s Zeppe’s turns out big, shareable pizzas and wings that travel well back to Hiram for watch parties and gatherings.
A short drive west of Hiram, Zeppe’s offers the kind of menu that works when you are feeding a big mixed group—think large pies, boneless wings, and breadsticks by the box. The crust leans slightly thicker and chewier, with a sauce that has a bit of sweetness many Ohioans expect. Order a couple of specialty pizzas plus a plain cheese or pepperoni to keep everyone happy.