01
Closest to Hockingport
Larry's Pizza & Subs
Coolville Village Center • Small-Town Carryout Pizzeria • Local Favorite
The go-to stop for a hot pizza without leaving the backroads between Hockingport and Coolville.
Larry's is the closest true pizzeria to Hockingport, and it feels exactly like the kind of small-town shop you hope to find after a day on the river. The crust is classic Midwest—sturdy, a little chewy, and built to hold plenty of toppings—and the prices are friendly enough for feeding a crowd. Call ahead for carryout, grab a pie and some subs, and you’re back on the road to Hockingport in minutes.
02
Best for creative pies
Avalanche Pizza
East Side Athens On East State Street • Artisan Pie Shop And Bakery • Destination Pick
A Athens-area institution known for wildly inventive specialty pies and quality ingredients.
If you’re willing to make the drive into Athens, Avalanche is the spot locals recommend when someone says they want “seriously good pizza.” The menu leans creative, with bold topping combinations, long-fermented dough, and an attention to detail you usually only see in bigger cities. It’s a smart choice when you want to impress a group or break up a cabin weekend with a proper food outing.
03
Game-day classic
Courtside Pizza
Uptown Athens Near Court Street • Sports-Bar Style Pizzeria • Best For Watching The Game
A lively, old-school Athens spot where pizza, pitchers, and game-day energy all show up in equal measure.
Courtside has long been a staple for Ohio University students and locals, thanks to its crisp-edged pies, generous cheese, and plenty of TVs. Compared to more experimental places, the menu sticks to straightforward, crowd-pleasing combinations that pair well with a cold drink. If you’re heading up from Hockingport to catch a big game and want a few pies on the table, this is an easy, reliable choice.
04
Best late-night slice
Goodfella's Pizza
Court Street Late-Night Strip • Walk-Up Slice Counter • Best After A Night Out
A grab-and-go slice joint that keeps the ovens hot well into the night on Court Street.
Goodfella's is all about big, foldable slices and fast service, especially when uptown Athens is buzzing. The menu skews simple—pepperoni, cheese, and a few classics—but the slices hit the spot when you want something satisfying without sitting down for a full meal. It’s a convenient stop if you’ve been in town for a show or a game and want a quick bite before the drive back toward Hockingport.
05
Best for delivery range
Domino's Pizza
Athens East State Street Corridor • National Delivery Chain Location • Best For Wide Delivery Range
A practical option when you need late-night delivery to cabins and rentals outside town.
While not as characterful as the indie spots, the Athens Domino’s earns its place on this list because it reliably reaches the scattered rentals and backroads between Athens, Coolville, and the Hockingport area. Online ordering, consistent pies, and extended hours make it useful when other kitchens have already closed. If convenience and delivery beat atmosphere and experimentation for the night, this is the number to keep handy.