Holiday Lakes may feel tucked away, but you are never far from a good pizza. Most locals head into nearby Willard for reliable, family-friendly pies, while a short drive opens up a few regional favorites in Norwalk and New London. Whether you want a classic sheet pizza for the whole crew or a bar pie during the big game, these spots cover the main cravings. Use this list as a starting point for your next low-key night at the lake.
Classic, no-nonsense pies that most Holiday Lakes regulars know by heart.
Bruno's is the kind of small-town pizza shop people grow up on and keep coming back to. Expect hearty, cheese-forward pies with a sauce that leans comforting rather than fancy, plus plenty of topping combos for feeding a crowd. Call ahead on weekend nights; it gets busy with both lake traffic and locals.
A lively sports bar where the pizza is as much a draw as the TVs.
If you want wings, cold beer, and a solid pizza all in one stop, the Varsity Club is an easy choice. Their pizzas come out with a crisped edge and plenty of cheese, ideal for sharing around a table during a game. It is loud, casual, and very Willard—in a good way.
A dependable option for pan, thin, and specialty pizzas when you are feeding a crowd.
East of Chicago leans into thick, pan-style crusts and loaded toppings, with plenty of build-your-own flexibility. Families appreciate the value, especially when you are grabbing a few large pies to bring back to the lake. It is not fancy, but it is consistent, filling, and easy to customize for picky eaters.
A Lake Erie–area staple known for its slightly thicker crust and generous cheese.
If you do not mind a short drive, Norwalk’s Cameo Pizza delivers a distinctly regional style that many lake-goers seek out. The crust strikes a balance between soft and chewy, with a slightly sweet sauce and a heavy hand on the cheese. It is a good pick when you want something a little different from the usual Willard lineup.
A straightforward, old-school pizza joint that keeps prices and pretension low.
New London Pizza House feels like stepping into another era, in the best way. Expect square-cut pies, familiar toppings, and a focus on value over trendiness. It is an easy swing-by if you are out for a drive south of Holiday Lakes and want to bring an affordable pizza back to the dock.