01
Classic Italian standout
Giovanni's Pizzeria e Ristorante Italiano
Historic Fairborn Main Street • Old-School Italian Pizzeria And Restaurant • Best Sit-Down Experience
A Dayton-area institution with hearty pies, red-sauce comfort dishes, and a lively dining room that draws regulars from all around Holiday Valley.
Giovanni's is where you go when you want pizza to feel like an occasion, not just a quick bite. The crust leans classic and sturdy, perfect for holding generous layers of cheese and toppings, and the house Italian dishes make it easy to please a mixed group. Expect a busy room on weekends, friendly service, and plenty of leftovers to take back to your rental or campsite.
02
Small-town charmer
Peabody's Ice Cream & Pizza
Enon Main Street Corridor • Small-Town Pizza And Ice Cream Shop • Best Family Stop
A cozy Enon shop that pairs crowd-pleasing pizzas with hand-dipped ice cream, perfect after a day on the road or nearby trails.
Peabody's feels like the kind of place every small town should have: simple, friendly, and focused on making comfort food well. The pizzas are straightforward and satisfying, with plenty of topping options and sizes that work for everything from kids’ dinners to hungry groups. Grabbing a cone or milkshake on the way out has become a bit of a local ritual, especially in warm weather.
03
Dayton-style essential
Marion's Piazza
North Springfield Shopping Strip • Large-Format Thin-Crust Pizzeria • Best For Big Groups
A roomy Springfield outpost of the beloved Dayton chain, known for square-cut thin crust and fast, efficient service.
If you want to feed a crowd without overthinking it, Marion's is an easy answer. The signature pies are baked on a crisp, thin crust and cut into small squares, making them ideal for sharing around a big table. The spacious dining room, quick turnaround, and predictable quality make it a go-to before movies, after youth sports, or on rainy camping evenings.
04
Downtown slice stop
Bada Bing! Pizzeria
Downtown Springfield • Casual Slice Shop And Bar • Best For A Quick Bite
A lively downtown spot where you can grab hefty slices, creative specialty pies, and a drink without leaving the city center.
Bada Bing! leans a little more urban than your typical small-town pizzeria, with big-fold slices and fun topping combos that reward repeat visits. It works especially well if you are already in downtown Springfield for events or brewery hopping and want something filling without a long sit-down meal. The vibe is relaxed and informal, making it a solid choice for a quick pre-show or post-game bite.
05
Road-trip classic
Cassano's Pizza King
Dayton-Springfield Corridor • Carryout-Focused Regional Pizza Chain • Best Takeout Option
A long-running regional chain offering crispy, edge-to-edge toppings and reliable takeout that travels well back to Holiday Valley.
Cassano's has been part of the local pizza landscape for decades, and its slightly sweet sauce and cracker-thin crust inspire real loyalty. This is the place to call when you want pizza ready on your way back from errands or day trips into Dayton or Springfield. Order a couple of larges with extra toppings, add some wings or a salad, and you have an easy crowd-pleasing spread back at the cabin or hotel.