01
Best for build-your-own pies
Mama Mary's Pizza
Airport Highway Corridor • Family-Friendly Carryout And Delivery Shop • Best For Customizable Pies
A Holland staple where generous toppings and consistent takeout make it an easy go-to on busy nights.
Mama Mary's leans into classic, crowd-pleasing pizza with plenty of topping combinations and sizes for any group. The crust lands in that sweet spot between soft and sturdy, so it holds up well to heavier toppings and extra cheese. It is the kind of place locals keep on speed dial for Friday nights, game days, and casual gatherings.
02
Old-school neighborhood favorite
Mike's Pizza
South Mccord Road • Classic Local Pizza Joint • Dependable Neighborhood Standby
Thin, slightly crispy crust and plenty of cheese make Mike's a reliable choice when you just want classic, no-fuss pizza.
Mike's feels like the archetypal hometown pizza shop, with straightforward pies that focus on crust, sauce, and cheese rather than gimmicks. The menu covers the essentials plus a few hearty specialty combos, and the portions are generous for the price. It is especially popular for takeout on weeknights, when you want something satisfying without leaving Holland proper.
03
Best for pizza and subs combo
Mancino's Pizza & Grinders
Spring Meadows / Centers Drive • Pizzeria And Grinder Shop • Great For Big Appetites
Thick, cheesy pizza and oversized baked grinders make Mancino's ideal when your group wants more than just a pie.
Mancino's is known as much for its toasted grinders as for its pizza, which features a thicker crust and plenty of cheese. It is a smart pick for families or coworkers who want to mix pizza with hearty sandwiches and salads in one order. The relaxed, no-frills setup and predictable portions make it especially useful for feeding a crowd near the Spring Meadows shopping area.
04
Best downtown Toledo option
Home Slice Pizza
Warehouse District, Downtown Toledo • Lively Urban Slice Shop And Bar • Best For A Night Out
A short drive from Holland, Home Slice serves big New York–style slices in a lively downtown setting.
If you are willing to head into downtown Toledo, Home Slice rewards the trip with foldable slices, creative toppings, and a buzzy bar atmosphere. It works equally well for a quick slice before a Mud Hens game or a relaxed night sharing pies and drinks with friends. The upstairs bar and street-side location add to the urban feel, making it a nice contrast to Holland's quieter strip of pizza shops.
05
Best for craft pizza fans
The Stubborn Brother Pizza Bar
Old Orchard Near University Of Toledo • Craft Pizza Bar With Full Service • Top Pick For Elevated Pies
Inventive toppings, quality ingredients, and a full bar make Stubborn Brother a destination-worthy pizza stop.
Located by the University of Toledo, Stubborn Brother feels more like a modern restaurant than a typical pizza joint, with a bar program and a dining room built for lingering. The pizzas lean artisan, with airy crusts and thoughtful combinations that go well beyond standard pepperoni and sausage. It is a great choice when you want something a step up from takeout without being overly formal, and it is still an easy drive from Holland.