01
Best overall pick
Valley Pizza Co.
Flushing Area • Small-Town Takeout Pizzeria • Local Favorite
A go-to for generously topped pies and friendly, no-fuss service a short drive west of Holloway.
Valley Pizza Co. feels like the kind of place where the staff knows half the customers by name, and the pies come loaded edge-to-edge with toppings. The crust lands in the sweet spot between chewy and crisp, making it easy to share a few different specialty pizzas with the table. Call ahead on weekend evenings, when locals line up for carryout.
02
Classic Ohio Valley style
DiCarlo's Pizza
Downtown St. Clairsville • Ohio Valley Square-Cut Pizzeria • Essential Regional Style
This long-running counter spot serves the signature square-cut pies that define pizza in the Ohio Valley.
If you have never tried Ohio Valley-style pizza, DiCarlo's in St. Clairsville is the place to start. Pans of crust and sauce are baked first, then finished with a shower of cheese and toppings as they come out of the oven, giving each bite a different texture than a typical pie. Expect a simple setup, quick service, and a steady stream of regulars grabbing boxes to go.
03
Best for family dinners
Giovanni's Pizza
St. Clairsville Side Streets • Family Italian Restaurant And Pizzeria • Best For Families
A sit-down spot where big pizzas, pasta, and subs make it easy to please a whole crew.
Giovanni's mixes classic pizza shop energy with a fuller Italian menu, so everyone at the table can find something they like. The pizzas lean hearty, with a slightly thicker crust, plenty of cheese, and lots of topping combinations to choose from. It is a comfortable choice for unhurried dinners after ballgames or shopping runs into town.
04
Best for big appetites
Fox's Pizza Den
Cadiz • Casual Regional Chain Pizzeria • Best For Big Groups
Known for its huge specialty pies and party-friendly portions, this Cadiz shop works well when you are feeding a crowd.
Fox's Pizza Den in Cadiz is popular with teams, church groups, and large families who want a lot of food without a lot of fuss. The menu runs from classic pepperoni and sausage pies to loaded specialty pizzas and wedgies, the chain's stuffed sandwich-style creations. Order a few different sizes and let everyone grab slices from the center of the table.
05
Most reliable chain option
Pizza Hut
Mall Road, St. Clairsville • National Pizza Chain Dine-In And Carryout • Late-Night Pick
A familiar option near the retail strip, with consistent pies, wings, and easy carryout or delivery.
When you are already out near the malls and big-box stores, the Pizza Hut in St. Clairsville is an easy stop for pan, hand-tossed, or stuffed-crust pizzas. The predictable menu means you can order for picky eaters or kids without much debate. It is also one of the more dependable choices for later-hours pizza in the area, especially on busy weekends.