01
Hometown staple
Main Street Pizza and Subs
Downtown Holmesville • Small-Town Slice Shop • Best Overall Pick
Classic, no-nonsense pizza made the way locals like it, right in the center of Holmesville.
This cozy spot on West Main Street is usually the first place Holmesville residents mention when you ask where to grab a pie. The menu sticks to the hits: well-topped pizzas, hearty subs, and familiar sides that work just as well for a quick weeknight dinner as they do for a ballgame party. Call ahead for busy evenings; it is popular with teams and families rolling through town.
02
Destination pies
Park Street Pizza
Sugarcreek • Creative Farm-To-Table Pizzeria • Worth The Drive
A modern small-town pizzeria known for quality ingredients, smart flavor combos, and a lively local crowd.
About a scenic drive from Holmesville, Park Street Pizza draws people from across Amish Country for its crisp, flavorful pies. Toppings lean seasonal and thoughtful, with plenty of options beyond the standard pepperoni-and-cheese routine. It is the place to go when you want a sit-down night out that still feels casual and very local.
03
Laid-back family pick
Charm Pizza Company
Charm • Pizza Buffet And Family Spot • Best For Families
A relaxed buffet-style pizza stop that keeps kids happy and groups well fed without breaking the bank.
Set in the tiny village of Charm, this pizzeria leans into comfort and volume: think plenty of hot pies coming out steadily and a friendly, small-town feel. It is an easy choice if you are touring the backroads and need to satisfy a mix of appetites quickly. Expect familiar toppings, simple salads, and a come-as-you-are vibe.
04
Game-night go-to
East of Chicago Pizza (Millersburg)
Millersburg • Carryout And Delivery Chain Pizzeria • Best For Takeout
Reliable, customizable pizzas that are easy to grab on the way home or have delivered to a rental or hotel.
For Holmesville residents and visitors staying in or around Millersburg, this East of Chicago location is a practical choice. The crust styles, toppings, and sauces are highly customizable, which makes ordering for a crowd straightforward. Pair a couple of loaded specialty pies with breadsticks and wings and you are set for a low-effort movie or game night.
05
Old-school classic
Coccia House
Wooster • Old-School Italian-American Pizza Joint • Classic Local Institution
A longtime Wooster favorite known for its hefty, cheese-laden pies and throwback dining room.
If you do not mind a slightly longer drive from Holmesville, Coccia House is a regional classic that many locals consider a rite of passage. The pizzas are generously topped, with a distinctive crust and sauce that keep regulars coming back decade after decade. Plan on a relaxed, old-fashioned sit-down experience, and do not be surprised if there is a wait on weekend evenings.