01
Best overall pick
Wedgewood Pizza Howland
Howland Township • Mahoning Valley Classic Pizzeria • Go-To Local Staple
A beloved Howland shop serving cheesy, generous pies that define the local take on Mahoning Valley pizza.
If you ask Howland locals where they order pizza, Wedgewood is the name you hear most. The pies are thick with cheese, well-sauced, and built to handle heavy toppings without getting soggy. It is a great choice when you are feeding a group and want the kind of classic, crowd-pleasing pizza people here grew up with.
02
Best for a night out
Salvatore's Italian Grill
Howland Center • Casual Italian Grill And Bar • Sit-Down Pizza And Pasta Spot
A comfortable Italian grill where you can pair well-made pizzas with pastas, salads, and a glass of wine.
Salvatore's is the move when you want pizza but also a full sit-down meal. Their pies come with a nicely baked crust and toppings that lean more Italian restaurant than corner slice shop, so it feels a bit more polished without being stuffy. It is ideal for date night, small celebrations, or when half the table wants pizza and the rest want pasta or veal.
03
Best for families
Pizza Works
Near Niles-Cortland Road • Family-Run Neighborhood Pizzeria • Family-Friendly Choice
A straightforward, family-oriented pizzeria known for consistent pies and easy weeknight dinners.
Pizza Works keeps things simple in the best way: solid crust, reliable toppings, and portions that make sense when you are feeding kids or a crew after practice. The menu usually goes beyond pizza with subs and wings, so everyone can find something. It is the kind of place where regulars are greeted by name and orders start to feel automatic.
04
Best old-school pies
Sunrise Inn
Downtown Warren • Historic Tavern-Style Pizzeria • Classic Regional Favorite
A long-running Warren institution that built its reputation on hearty, tavern-style pizzas and a comfy, old-school dining room.
Just a short drive from Howland Center, Sunrise Inn is where many locals first fell in love with pizza. The crust leans toward tavern-style, with a satisfying chew and plenty of cheese that crisps up around the edges. Go for a specialty pizza loaded with sausage and peppers, and enjoy it in a space that feels like it has been hosting regulars for decades.
05
Best for gourmet toppings
Red Plum Pizza & Pasta
East Warren • Modern Pizza And Pasta Cafe • Creative Pie Option
A cozy spot that mixes classic pies with more creative topping combinations and a full pasta lineup.
Red Plum is a nice pick when you want something a little different from the standard pepperoni-and-cheese routine. Their pizzas often feature thoughtful combinations, like fresh vegetables, specialty meats, and flavorful sauces that feel a notch above typical delivery options. Pair a pie with one of their pasta dishes or salads and it makes for a satisfying, slightly upscale-feeling dinner without leaving the neighborhood.