01
Closest to Hoytville
Padrone's Pizza
North Baltimore Village Center • Small-Town Carryout Pizzeria • Closest Slice To Hoytville
Small main-street shop turning out reliable pies that travel well back to Hoytville.
Just a few minutes west of Hoytville, Padrone's is the easy weeknight choice when you want pizza without a long drive. The menu sticks to the classics—pepperoni, deluxe, and meat-heavy specials—on a crust sturdy enough to stay crisp in the box. Call ahead on Friday and Saturday nights, when locals tend to flood the counter with carryout orders.
02
Best classic joint
Jac & Do's Pizza
Findlay West Side • Classic Ohio Pizza Parlor • Best For Group Dinners
Old-school Findlay parlor with shareable pies, big booths, and a steady weeknight buzz.
If you are making the short drive into Findlay with family or friends, Jac & Do's feels like the platonic ideal of a hometown pizza joint. Expect thin-to-medium crust, lots of cheese, and well-priced combo deals that make feeding a crowd straightforward. It is the kind of place where teams and birthday groups pile in after a game and nobody feels rushed to leave.
03
Best for game night
Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill
Findlay Near I-75 • Family Pizza And Sports Bar • Game-Day Crowd Pleaser
Lively regional favorite where big, saucy pizzas share the table with wings, apps, and plenty of TVs.
Beer Barrel is the spot when you want pizza plus a full grill menu and a roomful of game-day energy. Their pizzas lean generous on toppings and cheese, with specialty combinations that go well alongside wings and shareable appetizers. With lots of seating and screens, it is a natural meet-up point for watching a game after the drive in from Hoytville.
04
Best delivery bet
Heavenly Pizza
Findlay North Side • Delivery-Focused Neighborhood Shop • Best For Delivery Toward Hoytville
Locals lean on this spot for well-topped, slightly thicker-crust pies delivered fast and hot.
Heavenly Pizza is a go-to if you would rather have dinner come to you than leave the house. Their pizzas are sturdy, saucy, and generous with toppings, with plenty of specialty options alongside build-your-own combinations. Check their deals for larger orders; it is an efficient way to feed a hungry group without trekking far from Hoytville.
05
Worth the detour
Campus Pollyeyes
Downtown Bowling Green • College-Town Pizza And Stuffed Breadsticks • Worth-The-Drive Favorite
Beloved BGSU hangout known as much for its cheesy stuffed breadsticks as for its customizable pizzas.
If you are up for a slightly longer drive, Campus Pollyeyes in Bowling Green is a cult favorite that lives up to the stories. The pizzas are hearty and customizable, but the real draw is pairing a pie with their famously gooey stuffed breadsticks. Time your visit outside peak game nights and you will get the campus energy without the long waits.