01
Best overall pick
Pizzeria DiLauro
Downtown Chagrin Falls • Wood-Fired Italian Pizzeria • Destination For Date Night
A stylish, intimate spot known for char-blistered Neapolitan-style pies and a tight but thoughtful menu.
If you’re willing to circle for parking in Chagrin Falls, Pizzeria DiLauro rewards you with some of the most dialed-in pizza on the east side. The dough has a proper chew and airy crust, and toppings lean seasonal and Italian without feeling fussy. It’s an easy pick for date night or a relaxed dinner with a couple of friends over a bottle of wine.
02
Classic carryout favorite
Augie's Pizza & Ribs
East Of Chagrin Falls • Old-School Pizza And Rib Shop • Best For Big Takeout Orders
Thin, cheesy pies and generous portions make this longtime east-side staple a go-to for casual nights in.
Augie’s is the place locals call when there’s a game on, kids in the house, or a crowd to feed without overthinking it. The pizza is classic Northeast Ohio style: crisp-edged crust, plenty of cheese, and toppings that run from pepperoni to hearty house specialties. Add an order of ribs or wings and you’ve basically covered everyone’s cravings in one stop.
03
Upscale tavern pick
Crumb & Spigot
North Side Of Chagrin Falls • Chef-Driven Tavern With Pizza • Best For Creative Toppings
A polished neighborhood tavern where wood-fired pizzas share the spotlight with craft cocktails and small plates.
Crumb & Spigot is ideal when part of the group wants a proper dinner out and someone else just wants great pizza. The pies come out with nicely blistered crusts and toppings that go beyond the usual—think seasonal vegetables, specialty cheeses, and house-made sausage. Grab a seat at the bar or on the patio and treat the pizza as the centerpiece of a longer, more leisurely meal.
04
Most family-friendly
Mellow Mushroom
Pinecrest In Orange Village • Colorful Craft-Pie Chain • Family-Friendly Crowd-Pleaser
A lively spot at Pinecrest with a big menu, playful décor, and plenty of customizable pizzas for all tastes.
For families coming from Hunting Valley, Mellow Mushroom at Pinecrest is an easy meet-in-the-middle choice. The crust is substantial and chewy, with lots of room for piling on everything from classic pepperoni to funky, veggie-forward combinations. Kids stay entertained with the bright, whimsical space, while adults appreciate the beer list and the option to linger and stroll the center afterward.
05
Game-day staple
Master Pizza
Mayfield Heights Som Center Corridor • Casual Neighborhood Pizzeria • Game-Day Go-To
A reliable east-side chain known for thick, cheesy pies, loaded toppings, and efficient delivery.
Master Pizza in Mayfield Heights is built for those nights when you want solid, no-nonsense pizza fast. The crust runs from traditional to thicker styles, and the topping combos—like deluxe or meat-heavy options—are geared toward sharing during a game or movie night. It’s close enough to Hunting Valley for quick pickup, and the consistency keeps locals coming back.