01
Best overall pick
Six Hundred Downtown
Downtown Bellefontaine • Wood-Fired Artisan Pizzeria • Destination-Worthy Spot
Award-winning, hand-crafted pies in a lively historic-downtown setting.
Six Hundred Downtown is the spot locals point to when they want to show off just how good pizza in Logan County can be. The menu leans into classic Neapolitan-style pies with blistered crusts, quality toppings, and a big wood-fired oven as the star of the show. It’s worth planning ahead for, especially on weekends when the dining room fills up fast.
02
Best for thin-crust
Donatos Pizza
South Bellefontaine • Fast-Casual Thin-Crust Chain • Reliable Carryout Option
Crispy, edge-to-edge toppings make this a go-to for thin-crust fans.
If you like your crust crisp and your toppings spread all the way to the edge, Donatos is an easy choice. It’s especially handy for quick carryout on the way back to Huntsville or for feeding a crowd without much planning. Online ordering and predictable quality make it a dependable weeknight option.
03
Classic Ohio style
Cassano's Pizza King
East Bellefontaine • Old-School Party-Cut Pizzeria • Nostalgic Local Chain
Dayton-style, square-cut pies with a loyal local following.
Cassano’s brings that classic Ohio, tavern-style pizza experience a short drive from Huntsville. Expect a very thin crust, a light crackle on each bite, and toppings scattered right out to the rim, all cut into party squares. It’s a solid pick when you want something a little different from the big national chains and a bit of hometown nostalgia.
04
Late-night pick
Domino's Pizza
North Bellefontaine Corridor • National Delivery Chain • Fast Delivery Favorite
Customizable pies, wings, and more delivered quickly around the Huntsville–Bellefontaine area.
Domino’s is the practical choice when you want pizza to come to you, whether you’re in Huntsville, out by the lake, or staying near Bellefontaine. The menu is highly customizable, from crust style to sauces and extras like wings and sandwiches. It’s especially useful for late-night cravings or game-day orders when convenience matters most.
05
Best for families
Pizza Hut
Bellefontaine Retail Strip • Sit-Down Chain Pizzeria • Family-Friendly Choice
Familiar pan pizzas and roomy booths make it easy to bring the whole crew.
For a classic, no-surprises pizza night, the Bellefontaine Pizza Hut is an easy crowd-pleaser. The thick, buttery pan crust and familiar menu are especially popular with kids and mixed groups who all like something a little different. It works well for relaxed sit-down dinners after errands in town or as a simple stop before heading back toward Huntsville.