Independence sits at the crossroads of old-school Cleveland pizza traditions and the busy Rockside Road hotel corridor. Within a few minutes’ drive, you can find everything from crisp, square-cut pies to foldable New York–style slices. These five picks highlight the spots locals turn to for weeknight takeout, game-day gatherings, and late office lunches.
Thin, square-cut pies, generous toppings, and a no-frills, hometown feel.
Romito's is the spot locals mention first when you ask where to get pizza in Independence. The crust is on the thinner, slightly chewy side with those nostalgic, corner pieces everyone fights over. It’s a go-to for takeout on game nights, but there’s just enough dine-in space if you want to eat your pie fresh from the oven.
Big, shareable pies with a slightly thicker crust and plenty of classic Italian comfort dishes on the side.
Augie’s combines a neighborhood pizza shop vibe with a full Italian menu, so everyone in the group can find something they like. The pizza leans generous—lots of cheese, plenty of toppings, and a crust sturdy enough to hold it all. It’s an easy pick for family dinners, team celebrations, or feeding a hungry crowd without breaking the bank.
A Cleveland-born mini-chain known for big slices, loaded specialty pies, and fast service.
Just a few minutes from Independence, Rascal House is ideal when you want something quick but more interesting than basic chain pizza. You’ll find oversized slices, creative topping combos, and plenty of sides like wedges and wings to round out an order. It’s especially handy for hotel stays or office lunches when you need solid pizza delivered on time.
Lively, music-filled spot serving hefty pizzas, pastas, and bar favorites in a throwback setting.
Danny Boy’s feels like a mash-up of a family pizzeria and a music lover’s clubhouse, with memorabilia on the walls and plenty of TVs for catching the game. The pizzas run substantial, with chewy crusts and toppings that go heavy on the cheese and meat. It’s a fun choice when you want to make a night of it rather than just picking up a box to go.
Well-executed, traditional pies with a loyal following and consistently good takeout.
Antonio’s is a long-running local chain, and the Broadview Heights location is a dependable stop for grabbing pizza on your way back to Independence. Expect a slightly thicker, golden crust, balanced sauce, and toppings that stay put rather than sliding off. It’s the kind of place you keep on speed dial for Friday nights, office parties, and last-minute family dinners.