01
Best classic regional pick
Cassano's Pizza King
Greenville • Tavern-Style Thin-Crust Pizzeria • Local Favorite For Dayton-Style Pies
A long-running regional chain turning out cracker-thin crust pizzas that many Darke County locals grew up on.
If you want a true Dayton-area classic, Cassano's in Greenville is the nostalgic choice, with ultra-thin crust, edge-to-edge toppings, and a light hand on the sauce. It is the kind of place where people have a favorite combination and rarely change it, whether that is a loaded deluxe or simple pepperoni and banana pepper. Expect quick service, plenty of carryout orders, and a familiar, no-frills feel that suits a casual pizza night.
02
Best for customizable carryout
Marco's Pizza
Greenville - Shopping District • Carryout And Delivery Pizza Shop • Best For Build-Your-Own Pizzas
A convenient stop near the main Greenville shopping strip, known for hearty crusts and lots of topping options.
Marco's in Greenville is a go-to when you need to feed a crowd and want everyone to get exactly what they like. The menu leans into build-your-own pizzas with several crust styles, plus specialty pies that pile on toppings and cheese. It is primarily a carryout and delivery spot, making it a practical choice for game days, family gatherings, or nights when no one feels like cooking.
03
Best familiar family option
Pizza Hut
Eaton • Casual Dine-In And Carryout Chain • Best For Families And Big Groups
A sit-down-friendly Pizza Hut where Eaton families gather over pan pizzas, breadsticks, and pitchers of soda.
For many people around Ithaca, the Eaton Pizza Hut is the default choice for a simple, family-friendly dinner out. The classic pan crust and stuffed crust options keep kids happy, while the ability to mix and match toppings means adults can build something a bit more tailored. It works especially well when you want a familiar menu, table service, and room for a bigger group.
04
Best late-night delivery bet
Domino's Pizza
Eaton - Main Corridor • Delivery-Focused Pizza Chain • Best For Late-Night Convenience
Fast, reliable pizza delivery with lots of crust flavors and side options for late evenings or busy weeknights.
Domino's in Eaton is all about speed and consistency, which makes it handy for those nights when you realize it is already late and no one has eaten yet. The menu covers everything from simple one-topping pizzas to heavier specialty pies, plus wings, sandwiches, and desserts if you want to round out the order. Online ordering and tracking are straightforward, so you can place an order from Ithaca and time dinner around delivery.
05
Best cross-border detour
Pizza King
Richmond, Indiana • Regional Indiana Pizza Chain • Worth-The-Drive Specialty Pies
An Indiana original serving square-cut pizzas with a loyal following just across the state line in Richmond.
If you do not mind a bit of a drive, Pizza King in Richmond offers a different take on Midwestern pizza, with square-cut pies and a generous layer of toppings and cheese. It has a more old-school feel than many national chains, and regulars tend to have strong opinions about their ideal topping combinations. Pair a specialty pizza with a side of breadsticks and make it a fun dinner outing from Ithaca when you want something beyond the usual local options.