01
Best overall pick
Papa Rono's Pizza
Trenton • Classic Small-Town Pizzeria • Local Favorite
Beloved by Trenton locals for generous toppings, easygoing service, and consistently satisfying pies.
Just southwest of Jacksonburg, Papa Rono’s is the kind of no-frills pizzeria that keeps families coming back week after week. The crust is hearty without being too thick, and they don’t skimp on cheese or toppings, making their deluxe and meat-heavy pies especially popular. Call ahead for busy weekend evenings, when half the town seems to be picking up their order at once.
02
Best regional chain
LaRosa's Pizzeria
Trenton • Cincinnati-Style Family Pizzeria • Best For Families
A familiar regional name with a big menu, kid-friendly vibe, and reliable pizza for mixed tastes.
LaRosa’s brings its Cincinnati-style pies to Trenton, giving Jacksonburg families an easy option when everyone wants something different. The crust is on the thinner, softer side with a sweet-leaning sauce, and you can round out a pizza order with hoagies, salads, and wings. It’s a practical pick for weeknight dinners or team celebrations when convenience matters as much as the pizza.
03
Best comfort classic
Pizza Hut
Trenton • National Chain Dine-In And Carryout • Best For Pan Pizza Cravings
Go-to spot when you’re craving nostalgic pan pizza, breadsticks, and familiar chain comfort.
The Trenton Pizza Hut is the closest full-service big-name chain for Jacksonburg residents, and it leans into what the brand does best: buttery pan crusts, stuffed crust options, and indulgent sides. It’s an easy call for game nights or late-week cravings when you want something predictable and filling. Online deals and combo boxes make it especially appealing for feeding a crowd on short notice.
04
Best for Butler County tradition
Richards Pizza
Middletown • Old-School Butler County Pizzeria • Iconic Local Institution
Long-running local chain known for its distinctive sauce, edge-to-edge cheese, and loyal following.
A short drive north to Middletown gets you to Richards, a name many Butler County residents have grown up with. The pizzas come with a slightly sweet sauce, plenty of cheese, and toppings scattered right to the edge for a balanced bite. Pair a pie with their well-known steak sandwiches and you’ll see why people are willing to drive from small towns like Jacksonburg for a taste of this local classic.
05
Best value pick
Marco's Pizza
Middletown • Carryout And Delivery Chain • Great For Weeknight Takeout
Solid, affordable pizzas with lots of customization and frequent deals, ideal for easy carryout from Jacksonburg.
Marco’s in Middletown is a smart option when budget and convenience are top priorities but you still want a tasty pie. The crust has a bit more chew and structure than many chains, and you can customize with different crust flavors and hearty specialty combinations. Order ahead online, swing through for pickup, and you’ll be back on rural roads toward Jacksonburg before the cheese has even started to cool.